24
THE RIGHTS TO FOOD AND WATER
can put pressure on governments; lobbying and legal procedures, as well as activist
tactics such as grassroots mobilization and education campaigns can also be
effective. Ultimately, the goal should be to engage in a constructive dialogue with
all parties to bring about change.
Campaigning and advocacy should aim to generate awareness among minorities
and indigenous communities in an effort to ensure they contribute to decisionmaking processes that affect them. Insisting on a rights-based approach (RBA) can
be useful in this regard. The RBA is based on international human rights standards
with emphasis on non-discrimination, participation and accountability, while
paying particular attention to the different ability of people and groups to exercise
their rights depending on whether they are in positions of vulnerability or
empowerment.
Case study – Indigenous peoples in Botswana
The San (Basarwa) are hunters and gatherers who travel in small family bands
within defined territories. They hunt antelope, but their daily diet consists more of the
fruits, nuts and roots which they seek out in the desert, and water from underground
water sources. Hunting is a crucial part of their cultural heritage. When the Central
Kalahari Game Reserve (CKGR) was created in 1961 one of its objectives was to
protect the food supplies of the existing Bushmen (San) population in the area.
In the 1970s, the government of Botswana attempted to persuade the San to live
in permanent settlements within the reserve, where services like water, education
and health care could be easily provided. Later, it terminated essential services, to
get them to move to settlements outside the reserve. The government justified its
relocation policy by claiming that the San deplete the natural resources of the
reserve; that providing services to the CKGR is too expensive; or that it is ensuring
development and seeking to enhance their living standards.
The former CKGR residents are unable to adapt to the new surroundings; they
can no longer use their traditional knowledge and are exposed to changes in their
diet and way of life which have led to malnutrition. The water quality is deteriorating,
resulting in higher incidence of diarrhoea in children. Because the people have no
means of subsistence, there is an increased dependency on the state for food relief
and cash-for-work programmes.
The Basarwa and other indigenous peoples have responded by mobilizing,
demonstrating and establishing their own advocacy groups (First People of Kalahari
– FPK and Working Group for Indigenous Minorities in Southern Africa – WIMSA).
They have formed a negotiating team comprising representatives of the San people
in CKGR as well as the FPK, WIMSA and the Botswana Centre for Human Rights