A/HRC/12/32
page 15
indigenous groups and respecting their vision and teaching materials, and also hiring bilingual
teachers. Those initiatives revitalized the multicultural and bilingual programmes and schools,
with teaching materials in native languages. Bilingual education was seen as a tool to promote
cultural diversity and maintain the identity of the different communities.
50. A number of States expressed the view that the report and its theme were not only relevant
to the Expert Mechanism and to indigenous peoples but also to the wider work of the Human
Rights Council. They could provide the Council with the perspective and needs of indigenous
peoples for the effective realization of the right to education. This would help mainstream the
rights of indigenous peoples in the Council’s work and highlight the relevance of the Mechanism
to the Council’s work. The suggestion was made that the study be considered within the context
of the Council’s resolution and mandate on the right to education to ensure an indigenous
perspective.
51. Through many statements, States underlined the requirement that mainstream education
improve its approach in addressing the needs of indigenous peoples and that a sustained focus on
indigenous education would provide more opportunities for countries with indigenous
populations to learn from each other.
52. Carlos Mamani, member of the Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, stressed that the
right of indigenous peoples to self-determination was enshrined in the Declaration on the Rights
of Indigenous Peoples. He further pointed out that, concerning the right to education for
indigenous peoples, Governments should incorporate indigenous religions, customs and history
in the curricula as these are essential to indigenous communities. This approach should be
adopted from the primary level onwards. The importance of maintaining the languages of
indigenous peoples was particularly significant. Indigenous peoples should have the ability to
keep their identity through their own educational system rather than through mainstream
education.
53. Speaking on behalf of all indigenous observers, the Indigenous Global Caucus also
commended the Expert Mechanism for its draft study and acknowledged the limited resources
made available to the Mechanism to carry out the study. The Caucus recommended generating a
broader and more detailed report that would include broad consultation with indigenous peoples
as well as a body for monitoring the recommendations. It pointed out the need for a structure that
would include all the parties involved in the matter of education; that would guarantee the
participation of indigenous peoples; and that would pay particular attention to access to
education for indigenous girls. The Caucus also underlined the importance and impact that the
integration of indigenous peoples has in educational programmes, and the inclusion of their
history as a continuity that links the present with the civilizations that existed prior to
colonization. It pointed out the importance of emphasizing the need to maintain and perpetuate
traditional education and the indigenous “cosmovision”, so as to recognize, encourage and use
indigenous peoples’ methodologies for teaching and learning.
54. Concerning the concept of quality education, the Caucus recommended a broader
definition of the concept to include two fundamental elements: first, the inclusion in the
curriculum of one’s own culture and the historical connection with civilization prior to
colonization; and second, the development of those skills necessary to access universal
knowledge as human rights. It considered that incorporating policies that would permit access to