A/70/310
25. During his 2012 visits to Italy, the Special Rapporteur learned that the wages
received by migrant workers, often employed within the agricultural sector, were
often not sufficient to maintain an adequate standard of living. Reports suggested
migrants were being paid €20 or less for 10 hours of difficult manual work.
Complete impunity appeared to surround the situation of these workers, who were
being exploited by landlords and employers to benefit the Italian economy.
3.
Broader human rights violations
26. Unfortunately, the abuses of migrants’ rights go far beyond the significant
economic exploitation that is commonly experienced. Unethical recruitment
practices can facilitate a broad spectrum of interrelated and mutually reinforcing
human rights abuses.
27. It is common for migrants recruited from abroad to have severe restrictions
placed on their freedom of movement in countries of destination. Exploitative
employers, facilitated by recruitment intermediaries, will often restrict the ability of
migrants to switch employers and/or leave the country to return home, increasing
their dependence and willingness to complete tasks in poor conditions for low
wages.
28. Violence and intimidation are also perpetrated against migrants by both
unscrupulous recruiters and employers. Such violence can be used as a method of
control over migrants who challenge their treatment during the migration process, in
the workplace in countries of destination, and in pre-departure training centres and
accommodation. It has been reported that supervisors within companies or domestic
households employing migrants, will exert violence if migrants do not perform their
work functions as expected. Sexual harassment and sexual violence are particular
risks faced by female migrants working in different sectors. Private agencies recruit
many female migrants to work within domestic households, which operate outside
the formal economy and in many countries are excluded from labour law
protections. Female migrant workers are therefore left in an extremely precarious
situation, working behind closed doors, heavily dependent upon their employer, and
without any formal protection mechanism. Female migrant workers in such
situations have reported incidences of violence, including sexual violence.
29. The precariousness of the situation of migrant workers can additionally lead to
abuses of their economic, social and cultural rights. Housing can often lead to
various human rights issues. In cases where employers offer housing, this can be
used as an opportunity for further exploitation, as migrants are easier to control than
local labour. In other cases, exploitative employers in countries of destination
provide housing but this can be used to further control and exploit migrants, as it
makes them readily available to perform work. In other cases, migrants can be left
to finance their living and food costs independently. The need to minimize costs can
lead migrants to live in extremely poor housing conditions, with many living in
accommodation lacking basic infrastructure and services, including sanitation,
electricity and potable water. Recruiters and subagents can also play a role in
arranging and charging for housing, which can further increase their control over
and exploitation of migrants. Access to other forms of social protection can also be
problematic for migrants. Some migrants have access to healthcare provided
through their employment, but this is highly variable, leaving many highly
vulnerable if they experience problems with their health.
8/26
15-13569