A/74/358
condemned as complicit in the actions of the Government of Israel by fellow students
and organizations aligned with the political “left”. 30
24. The Special Rapporteur received numerous reports that in countries in the
Middle East and North Africa, Jews are frequently conflated with Israel and Zionism,
even in countries with a deep history of Jewish life. Literature demonizing Jews is
prevalent in the media in the region. 31 It was reported that school textbooks in Saudi
Arabia contained antisemitic passages, with some even urging violence against
Jews. 32 In August, the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination
expressed serious concern “about the existence of hate speech, in particular hate
speech directed against Israelis, which at times fuels antisemitism towards this group,
in certain media outlets, in particular those controlled by Hamas, as well as on social
media, in public officials’ statements and in school curricula and textbooks, which
also fuels hatred and may incite violence” (CERD/C/PSE/CO/1-2, para. 19 (c)).
25. Although there are small Jewish populations in the Asia-Pacific region,
representatives reported some particularly concerning examples of pervasive
antisemitic rhetoric, often reportedly stemming from the popular association of all
Jews with Israel and its policies. 33 For example, over 57 per cent of teachers and
lecturers and 53.74 per cent of students in Indonesia agreed with a survey statement
asserting that “Jews are the enemies of Islam”. 34
D.
Antisemitic violence: regional trends
26. A number of exceptionally violent antisemitic incidents have had an outsized
impact on Jewish individuals’ sense of security in recent years. On 27 October 2018,
a gunman attacked the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pennsylvania, United States,
murdering 11 congregants and injuring 7 others in the deadliest attack on Jews in
United States history. His comments during the attack and his social media activity
on the days preceding it revealed a belief in a host of antisemitic conspiracy theories
rooted in a far-right, white supremacist ideology. 35 Six months later, on 27 April 2019,
a gunman similarly motivated by white supremacist ideology killed one congregant
and wounded three others at a synagogue in the Poway community in California. 36
27. Earlier, between 2012 and 2015, French citizens carried out violent attacks
resulting in deaths at a kosher supermarket in Paris, at the Jewish Museum of Belgium
and at a Jewish day school in Toulouse. In 2015, a Danish citizen who had pledged
loyalty to the Islamic State carried out multiple attacks in Copenhagen, including one
outside a synagogue while a bat mitzvah was being celebrated, killing a volunteer
security guard. The alleged perpetrators in all four of the above -mentioned cases were
__________________
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
19-16257
Based on consultations with Jewish communities.
Examples: in Saudi Arabia, the newspaper Al-Iqtisadiyya printed an editorial cartoon showing a
grinding machine in the shape of the Star of David, grinding Gazans into skulls. In Algeria,
Echourouk El Youmi published an article claiming that Jews had been plotting against Muslims
for centuries, that Jews were responsible for most of the disasters that had befallen Muslims and
that Jews controlled the media, cinema, art and fashion. In Qatar, the privately owned Al-Raya
newspaper published a cartoon showing a witch with a Star of David wand causing inter-Arab
disputes.
See www.adl.org/resources/reports/teaching-hate-and-violence.
Based on consultations with Jewish community representatives from Indonesia.
See https://conveyindonesia.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Survey-Nasional-KeberagamaanGenZ.pdf.
See www.splcenter.org/hatewatch/2018/10/28/analyzing-terrorists-social-media-manifestopittsburgh-synagogue-shooters-posts-gab.
See www.nbcsandiego.com/news/local/New-Details-Emerge-in-Deadly-Poway-SynagogueShooting-511375582.html; and https://ctc.usma.edu/terrorist-attacks-jewish-targets-west-20122019-atlantic-divide-european-american-attackers/.
9/23