A/79/169
that, despite the absence of the inclusion of these persons in public decision -making,
they enjoy their civil, cultural and socioeconomic rights without discrimination, is
fundamental. Other disenfranchisement mechanisms are sometimes observed, such as
gerrymandering 34 or language requirement tests prior to exercising the right to vote.
These are illegitimate measures that have disproportionate consequences on the right
of persons belonging to minorities to effectively participate in decision-making
processes. Such measures should therefore be avoided when they directly affect the
rights of persons belonging to a minority to effectively participate in decision -making.
23. As the focus is on the third component of States, Government, when
investigating institutional designs and their impact on the effective participation of
persons belonging to minorities in decision-making processes and their
implementation, two important underlying factors, related to population and territory,
should be examined. The first is linked to the definition of the State population and
the second to the territorial distribution of different population groups on the State’s
territory. How and why they may affect institutional designs promoting the effective
participation of persons belonging to minority groups will be demonstrated.
24. Minorities are always defined as a group of the population of a country that is
numerically smaller than half of the total population and that shares some common
characteristics that differentiate its members from the rest of the population. 35 In that
respect, the way in which the entire population of the State is defined may be inclusive
or exclusive of persons belonging to minorities, allowing more or less room for their
effective participation, as regards both matters of concern to them and th eir
contribution to the nation as a whole. The Charter of the United Nations unites
“nations” – as the name of the organization indicates – represented by States, as
requested under the membership criteria set forth in article 4, paragraph 1, of the
Charter, as a consequence of which the international organization created in 1945
with the Charter as its backbone is implicitly based on the model of nation States. It
is therefore extremely important to see how minority groups relate to the nation,
within a national polity. For example, a Constitution which defines the nation in such
terms (for example, in the case of Nepal: “All the Nepalese people, with multiethnic,
multilingual, multi-religious, multicultural characteristics and in geographical
diversities, and having common aspirations and being united by a bond of allegiance
to national independence, territorial integrity, national interest and prosperity of
Nepal, collectively constitute the nation”) 36 can be considered very supportive of
persons belonging to minorities. Similarly, a State that defines itself as a plurinational
State 37 or a multiethnic State 38 , or whose Constitution include a declaration to
“recognise and uphold the multi-ethnic, multi-racial, multi-religious and multi-cultural
character of our Nation”, 39 shall be open to the effective participation of persons
belonging to minorities in society as a whole. Conversely, defining the State as
belonging to – or being constituted by – only one ethnic, national, religious or
linguistic group will make it more difficult to guarantee the effective participation of
__________________
34
35
36
37
38
39
12/20
In para. 90 of its thematic comment No. 2, the Advisory Committee of the Council of Europe
strongly asserted that “State parties should not adopt measures which aim to reduce the
proportion of the population in areas inhabited by persons belonging to national minorities”.
For reflections on the definition of minorities, see A/74/160.
Translation of the Constitution of Nepal of 20 September 2015. Available at https://ag.gov.np/
files/Constitution-of-Nepal_2072_Eng_www.moljpa.gov_.npDate-72_11_16.pdf.
Following the adoption of a new Constitution that entered into force on 7 February 2009, Bolivia
has since defined itself as the “Plurinational State of Bolivia”, pursuant to article 1 of the
Constitution.
Constitution of China, eleventh preambular para. Available at https://english.www.gov.cn/
archive/lawsregulations/201911/20/content_WS5ed8856ec6d0b3f0e9499913.html .
Constitution of Zambia (as amended in 2016), seventh preambular para. Available at
www.parliament.gov.zm/sites/default/files/documents/amendment_act/Constitution%20of%20
Zambia%20%20(Amendment),%202016-Act%20No.%202_0.pdf.
24-13136