358. The newly established remedy of tutela enabled any citizen to seek before
the courts the protection of his fundamental rights. The tutela system tended
to favour the complainant, who was under no obligation to appear with an
attorney, to cite norms of the Constitution or to give any juridical
foundation to his case. Unless the accused party refuted the allegations
within three flays, the substance of the tutela report was deemed to be true
and measures necessary to end the violation were ordered.
359. New provisions had also been introduced to deal with states of
emergency. The state of siege had previously been used to induce members of
armed groups to return to civil society as well as to provide protection from
intimidation and threats for judges and witnesses involved in drug-trafficking
trials. In 1990, the Supreme Court had found some of the decrees promulgated
during the state of siege, in particular those relating to restrictions of
trade-union freedoms, to be unconstitutional and a bill had been introduced
providing that human rights norms could be limited under exceptional
circumstances but never suspended. The new Constitution stipulated that
statutory laws could specify what limitations might be placed on rights in a
time of upheaval, but those limitations did not apply to the non-derogable
rights referred to in article 4, paragraph 2, of the Covenant.
360. Referring to the impact of guerrilla warfare and drug trafficking on the
Government's efforts to comply with the provisions of the Covenant, the
representative said that guerrilla activities directed against the civilian
population posed very complex human rights and public order problems,
particularly as they were mainly confined to rural areas in which the State
could maintain only a limited presence. Guerrilla warfare had frequently led
to retaliation by civilians, who had formerly been entitled by law to form
armed groups under military protection for the purpose of self-defence.
Beginning in 1989, negotiations with the guerrillas had helped to reduce the
direct participation of landowners in drug trafficking and had curbed
retaliatory action against those suspected of ties with guerrilla groups. It
had also been decided to abolish penalties for those accused of membership in
armed self-defence groups declared illegal by the Government, provided that
they had not committed other crimes.
361. With respect to politically motivated murders, he noted that the
elections to the Constituent Assembly held in 1991 had not been accompanied by
general acts of violence or intimidation. Among the guerrilla groups that had
participated for the first time in national elections, only the former
People's Liberation Army had been affected by violence committed by groups
trying to sabotage or obstruct the peace process. Furthermore, cases where
members of the armed forces had been involved in paramilitary activities had
sharply declined and seemed to involve only low-ranking members of the armed
forces corrupted by drug traffickers in the local areas where they were
serving. A number of police officers were currently under investigation for
alleged participation in so-called "social clean-up vigilante groups". Only
two rural massacres had been reported in 1991, compared to dozens in 1988 and
1989, and they were still under investigation. In 1991, a number of
paramilitary groups had been disarmed in areas where their activities had been
very widespread and efforts had also been made to increase the presence and
visibility of the army in areas where there was evidence of large-scale
paramilitary activities.
-85-