E/CN.4/2002/24/Add.1
page 2
Summary
At the invitation of the Australian Government and pursuant to Commission on Human
Rights resolution 2000/14 (III) of 17 April 2000, the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms
of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance undertook a mission to
Australia from 22 April to 10 May 2001. The purpose of this mission was to enable the
Special Rapporteur to evaluate the impact, on the various components of the Australian
population, of legislation and governmental policy in the area of action to combat racism, racial
discrimination and xenophobia. Particular stress was laid on the situation of the Aboriginal
peoples and the Torres Strait Islanders, especially in the light of the information reaching the
Special Rapporteur concerning the discriminatory character of the Native Title Amendment
Act 1998. Other information related to the difficulties in the process of reconciliation between
Indigenous and non-Indigenous inhabitants, and the discriminatory nature of the laws on
mandatory sentencing enforced in Western Australia and the Northern Territory, which had led
to an excessive percentage of young Aboriginals among the prison population. The Special
Rapporteur also wished to examine in situ the policy of multiculturalism underlying Australia’s
immigration policy and the social cohesion of the country.
At the end of his visit, the Special Rapporteur noted that substantial efforts had been
made by the Australian Government to end racism and racial discrimination. A number of
institutions - anti-discrimination commissions or human rights and equal opportunity
commissions - have been established at the federal level and in the federated states to combat
these phenomena. Programmes aimed at improving the living conditions of the Indigenous
peoples exist, even if they have not yet succeeded in producing the desired results. Recognition
of ethnic diversity and the promotion of inter-ethnic harmony undoubtedly constitute an ideal
policy for consolidating the Australian nation, provided it does not waver under the influence of
electoral considerations.
In addition, the question of reconciliation with the Aboriginal peoples remains
outstanding, because it affects the foundations of the Australian State and conflicting cultural
values. For the Aboriginals, despite the democratic foundations of the Australian State and its
desire to incorporate all its ethnic components on an egalitarian basis, this State is a
manifestation of colonization, whose consequences remain to this day, notably through the
limitation of their land rights, the tragedy of the abducted children, cultural clashes and highly
precarious living conditions outside the wealth of the majority of Australians. In their view, the
resolution of conflicts is dependent on negotiation on equal terms between Australia’s governors
and those who originally possessed the continent, the eminent owners of the Australian lands, of
which they have been dispossessed, particular account being taken of their indissoluble links
with the land. The land question remains crucial and is the key to the Australian problem. The
Commonwealth Government and the dominant political forces mainly take a forward-looking
approach which, while envisaging the possibilities of remedying the consequences of past
actions, wishes to reduce their effects on the building of a new nation. There is undoubtedly a
medium-term character in the positions displayed by the various protagonists, and the Australian
people has on many occasion succeeded in finding the catalysts for dialogue in order to restore
confidence and ensure peaceful coexistence.