European Union or all African Group states will vote the
same way. In this case, NGOs will need to lobby for the
support of the group. Group or block voting is increasing.
This is a serious concern because positions are becoming
polarized with greater North–South divides appearing
every year. When such group voting comes into play with
regard to country-specific Resolutions, the seriousness of
the human rights situation in that country may not play a
significant role in the outcome of the Resolution. As a
result, the strongest Resolutions usually concern
diplomatically-isolated countries. Once adopted by the
CHR, all Resolutions go to the ECOSOC for approval
and then to the General Assembly.
Networking
The CHR provides a good opportunity for networking
with experts and other NGOs. Use the coffee shop and
restaurant to make informal contacts and set up meetings.
Your presence in Geneva provides the opportunity to
meet with officials and experts working in all the Genevabased agencies, such as the ILO, OHCHR, UNAIDS,
UNHCR, etc. UN SRs (see section 4.2) present their
reports to the CHR and they often hold briefings for
NGOs. Every lunchtime there are meetings organized by
NGOs on a variety of issues to which experts are often
invited to speak. These events are useful for making contacts with people who could be helpful in your work. You
may wish to organize a meeting with other NGOs working on similar areas to inform others about an issue or
discuss solutions to a problem.
4.2 Special procedures
The purpose of special procedures is to monitor human
rights problems and report on them to the CHR. The special procedures consist of an individual (called a Special
Rapporteur or Special Representative [SR] or Independent
Expert [IE]) or a group of individuals (a working group).37
Some of the working groups and SRs deal with thematic mandates, that is, specific human rights problems
such as disappearances, education or racism, while other
working groups and SRs address country-specific situations focusing on a state where there are serious human
rights violations. See Annex 6.5 for a complete list of
country-specific and thematic mandates. There is no specific mandate for minorities; however, many special procedures have addressed minority issues. Minorities should
use all of the special procedures relevant to their concerns.
Bringing minority issues to the attention of a variety of
different special procedures may contribute to mainstreaming minority protection in the UN.
Unlike the treaty monitoring bodies, which can only
address issues in states that have ratified the particular
MINORITY RIGHTS: A GUIDE TO UNITED NATIONS PROCEDURES AND INSTITUTIONS
treaty, the special procedures can examine the situation in
all states. This makes them particularly useful for NGOs
in states that are not a party to the main human rights
treaties. Special procedures can bring situations that other
human rights mechanisms cannot address to international
attention. NGOs play an important role in the special
procedures system. They provide information to the special procedures on both general human rights situations
and on specific violations, and are often vital in advocating for the establishment of a special procedure on a specific theme or country.
The effectiveness of the special procedures, and their
openness to NGOs, is to a large extent dependent on the
individual appointed to the position. All of these experts
– whether IEs or SRs – serve in their personal capacity for
a maximum of six years and are expected to be politically
independent; however, they are appointed by the states of
the CHR; appointment is a political process. They are not
paid for their work and receive only limited research and
administrative support from the OHCHR. All experts
produce reports for the CHR and the GA on their work.
(These reports can be found by selecting the relevant link
on the thematic mandate page: http://www.unhchr.ch/
html/menu2/7/b/tm.htm or the country mandate page:
http://www.unhchr.ch/html/menu2/7/a/cm.htm of the
OHCHR website.) The CHR defines the scope of the
mandate and may request IEs to include certain themes in
their reports. NGOs can lobby for the CHR to request
that particular attention be paid to minorities.
The mandates of the different special procedures vary;
however, there are a number of common elements. (The
mandate of any particular special procedure can be found
in the CHR Resolution that created it; see the OHCHR
website.)
Information gathering
Most special procedures research issues relating to their
mandate using information received from governments,
other international institutions, NGOs and UN agencies.
The procedures most obviously relating to minority issues
include the SR on racism, the SR on freedom of religion,
and for minorities who also identify as indigenous, the SR
on indigenous peoples. However, many other special procedures address issues of concern to minorities and these
procedures could also be of value. In addition, encouraging special procedures that have not as yet paid sufficient
attention to minority concerns is important in order to
raise the visibility of minorities within the UN system.
Two examples of thematic special procedures addressing
minority concerns are the SRs on health and on adequate
housing. The first report, in 2003, of the SR on the right
of everyone to the enjoyment of the highest attainable
standard of physical and mental health, emphasized non29