bodies tend to be the most political ones and the experts
that are most likely to be sympathetic to minority concerns do not have any real power. NGOs must always
remember that the UN is a club of states; therefore, you
must be realistic in the achievements you strive for. The
UN is only as effective as its member states allow it to be
and, unfortunately, when it comes to issues of human
rights – and in particular minority rights – the UN has
not been as effective as it could be.
Whether it is about respect for minority rights or the
maintenance of peace, the primary concern of governments tends to be the potential disruption that they
expect, and fear, as a result of minorities asserting their
rights. They often assume that recognizing minority
rights, or granting special treatment – in particular any
arrangements delegating political and economic functions
to groups – will fuel secessionist claims that would threaten national unity, political independence and territorial
integrity. In cases affecting what some states call ‘their
own nationals’ (members of the same ethnic, linguistic or
religious group living in other states), unilateral state
action across international boundaries can lead to an
unfortunate politicizing of minority issues and increases
rather than reduces tension. Ignorance and lack of understanding, as well as doctrines of superiority and racism,
constitute further stumbling blocks.
NGOs using UN procedures in their advocacy for
minority rights need to recognize these governmental fears
and develop strategies to overcome them. One means of
doing this is for minority groups and their representatives
to approach the monitoring procedures with constant reference to the international standards, and with moderation
and political realities in mind. These human rights mechanisms are not forums for dealing with the right of selfdetermination or claims for secession. Self-determination
and secession are rights that minorities do not enjoy under
UN international instruments, and addressing these issues
is beyond the jurisdiction and power of the monitoring
bodies. For effective responses, for both protection and
prevention purposes, it is important to play by the rules,
even if some may consider them limited and restricted in
scope.
It is important to keep in mind that respect for minority rights is in the interest of both minority groups and
governments. Much depends on the political wisdom and
good faith of governments and minority groups when
making use of the monitoring and assistance procedures.
NGOs should also remember when using UN mechanisms that they should be seen as a tool in a broader
advocacy campaign. Getting strong Concluding Observations from a treaty body or making an intervention at the
Working Group on Minorities (WGM) or the Commission on Human Rights (CHR) will be unlikely to have a
6
big impact on the lives of minorities without follow-up
work nationally. The type of follow-up that will be the
most effective will depend on various criteria, including
the national situation and the available resources of the
NGO or NGOs undertaking the work.
Using the media at the UN in Geneva
For NGOs who visit the UN, a good way of increasing pressure
on governments is to take advantage of the media opportunities that are available in Geneva.
Located within the UN Palais des Nations building are
numerous journalists from international press agencies and
regional and national newspapers, radio and television media.
A directory of accredited journalists is available from the UN
Information Service, although this can be difficult to obtain
and is not made widely available to NGOs. Alternatively the
press centre (Salle de presse 1 and 2) and specific offices of
members of the press can be visited directly. Staff at the
press centre can assist you to locate relevant journalists and
information can be provided to them in printed form by using
the ‘mailbox’ service outside the main press room (Salle de
presse 1). Email, telephone and fax numbers for specific journalists are available from the directory of accredited journalists or by contacting the main press room. Telephone calls
from within the UN to numbers located in Geneva are free.
Notices, advertising NGO events, for example, can be posted on the press notice board at the press centre, although
authority to do this should be obtained in advance through
staff at the centre or through the Association of Accredited
Correspondents (ACANU). If you wish to organize a press
briefing this can be arranged with the assistance of ACANU, or
the UN Information Service, who will be able to advise on the
availability of rooms and additional means to inform members
of the press. The NGO Liaison Office may also be able to help.
In all your dealings with the press, it is advisable to provide
them with your information in the form of a clear, well-prepared press release or notification, including details of how
they can contact you if they are interested in your work or
issues. For contact details of the UN Information Service and
the NGO Liaison Office, see Annex 6.1.
The UN human rights system is constantly evolving. New
procedures are created and new international instruments
adopted, while other procedures are abandoned. NGOs
working with the UN should try to keep up to date with
developments in order to take advantage of any new
opportunities.
The current climate at the UN means that there is
potential for developments on minority issues. A high priority for the UN at the time of the 10th anniversary of the
genocide in Rwanda has been ensuring that genocide cannot happen again. The UN Secretary-General, Kofi Annan,
MINORITY RIGHTS: A GUIDE TO UNITED NATIONS PROCEDURES AND INSTITUTIONS