E/CN.4/2006/16
page 13
values of one group or community on minority groups, and hence the denial, overlooking or
negation of the values of those other groups or communities. The desire to civilize and to
transmit cultural and scientific progress constitute, for example, ideological stances justifying
colonial and imperial domination. Identity-related tension is founded, in a multicultural society,
in the confrontation between the assertion of intangible national values, expressions of the
dominant group or community’s values, set up as a unique model and reference point for
national identity, and either the questioning of these values, or demands for account to be taken
in these national values of the values of minority groups and communities in the nation. While
multiculturalism is the common dominant characteristic of most modern societies, the way in
which it is handled is more often than not makeshift, reflecting the ideological content of its
theoretical models. Such theoretical models and political practice are profoundly influenced by
several factors: the centrality of the question of identity in a context of globalization, the
political emphasis on efforts to combat terrorism, and the resurgence of old and new forms of
racism, discrimination and xenophobia.
34.
The model of republican integration, the modern incarnation of integration - assimilation,
constructs national unity on values viewed as the foundation of the republican political system.
These values are stated as the expression of social and political progress and of a secular order.
Political and social progress is reflected in the values of justice, equality and the primacy of the
individual over membership of a community. Secularism, the expression of the separation of
church and State, promotes the republican unity of society over the religious and cultural
diversity of its components. Republican integration takes precedence over the maintenance of
specific cultural or religious identities. The political exploitation of these factors, including
through the rhetoric of “defending national identity and culture”, feeds into political platforms
and is a central element in the increase in racism, discrimination and xenophobia throughout the
world. This model, displaying a profound refusal of cultural diversity, postulates the cultural
dispossession of minority communities, of the immigrant, as a necessary precondition for
national integration. The questioning of the cultural invisibility which results for minority
communities is an indicator of an identity crisis in a multicultural society. In this regard the
current crises in Europe, and particularly in France, are testament, through the exacerbation of
racism, discrimination and xenophobia, to a profound reconstruction of identity, a question
overlooked in the European construction. The sound and fury of these events, through the link
between social, political and economic demands and the affirmation of identity, constitute the
outward signs of the cracks and fissures in the old fabric of identity and the slow and painful
emergence of a new, multicultural, national identity.
B. Anti-Semitism and Christianaphobia
35.
The resurgence in anti-Semitism may be illustrated by three concomitant manifestations:
the increase in individual acts, the resilience of intellectual legitimization, and political
exploitation. The most dramatic and symbolic manifestation of individual acts of anti-Semitism
concerns the profanation, the desecration of tombs and places of worship. While such
profanation affects all religions, those affecting places identified as Jewish are more common in
many countries, particularly in Europe. Thus, in France, instances of profanation increased from
a level of 30 incidents at Jewish cemeteries and places of worship in 2003 to 91, from 13 to 87
for Muslims, and from 38 to 94 for Christians. Three groups stand out among those arrested:
the extreme right or skinhead neo-Nazi Movement, young “satanists”, and young people with a
gamut of motivations, ranging from support for the Palestinian people to aping television and