Diversity and Community Relations Judges, UK on Item VI
Yes, thank you madam Chairperson and also Independent Expert for giving me the opportunity
to speak today. I am Judge Kamil from the UK.
The UNDM provides specifically that persons specifically belonging to minorities have the right
to participate effectively in cultural, religious, social, economic and public life. Unfortunately,
despite some progress there are many challenges that continue to impede effective
participation of minorities in economic life in the countries where they live. Often in spite of
educational achievements they still face obstacles in their access in gaining employment. It is
well established that in addition to providing economic security and advancement, employment
encourages broader social advancement. It provides a route out of poverty in is central to
efforts and programs that are directed towards poverty reduction and inclusion in the economic
life of society.
Speaking as a Judge from the United Kingdom, my involvement in affirmative activities to
promote the rights of minorities includes clearing the path towards success to judicial positions
in the UK and the formation of a group of judges called Diversity and Community Relation
Judges. Access to a judicial position in the UK has often been perceived as a bar to persons who
did not fit the stereotype of white, male, upper-class, Christian and middle aged. Thus
apparently ruling out anyone who was from an ethnic, national, religious, or linguistic minority.
However as set out in several human rights law instruments – special measures or affirmative
action are very effective in addressing inequality of treatment and creating an opportunity for
minorities to participate effectively in economic life. The use of special measure is a
fundamental part of the realisation of the right to equality. Such measures can include training
and recruitment initiatives or quotas in public or private sector employment to promote access
to labour markets for minorities.
As regards to judiciary in England and Wales, much effort has been deployed to secure access
of qualified minorities to the bench. In addition to positive measures in judicial appointments
commission has been established to monitor appointments for judicial positions and to ensure
that the judiciary is fairly representative of the composition of society. The significant increase
of the number of minority judges states such as United Kingdom have recognised that
participation of minorities in economic and public life benefits the wider society. Participation
of minorities in the judiciary can promote access to economic participation and convey trust in
judiciary from persons belonging to minority groups despite progress a lot more needs to be
done. Minorities whether as a result of non-dominance or numerical size should benefit from
economic participation and the opportunities offered to other members of society. Therefore, it
is important that more effort and many more countries be deployed to take into account the
rights and needs of minorities. Successful practices such as the recruitment of minorities in the
judiciary as a way out of poverty should be replicated. So finally, overall it is through the
implementation of policies and strategies towards a better and more effective participation of
minorities in economic life that we will all benefit from a more peaceful and a more inclusive
society. Thank you.