E/CN.4/2006/5/Add.2
page 18
83.
The Special Rapporteur notes that the reasons for this violence are manifold and
complex, but she has also observed that in most cases the violence has unfolded along religious
lines: it is noticeable that the instigators of this violence have found that they can gain more
support if they put their arguments in religions terms. Religious beliefs not only constitute a
very emotional issue in Nigeria, but also provide a relatively simple and easy way to identify an
opponent.
84.
These instances of violence are striking in their intensity. In each case, a great number of
killings occurred in only a few days. This also shows that a very significant portion of the
population took part in the killings or has been affected by them. For this reason among others,
the killings are still very much in the minds of all those living in the places affected by the
violence. So many people have been implicated in - and suffer from - the violence that a
majority of the people in those places live in an atmosphere of fear, anger and sadness which, in
a way, prevents the population from returning to normal life. In some places, the Special
Rapporteur felt an atmosphere of real tension as if the violence had occurred more recently than
it actually did.
85.
In the many consultations held during her visit, especially with representatives of
religious groups, the Special Rapporteur clearly felt a high level of tensions and strong
indications that the situation could degenerate into a conflict of much larger intensity. Members
of religious communities and representatives of non-governmental organizations often expressed
their fear of further violence and their exasperation with regard to the current situation. Some of
them even warned that members of one or the other community could not contain their
frustration much longer and asserted that dissatisfaction and sometimes anger were affecting an
increasing number of Nigerians.
86.
A significant number of interlocutors at various levels and from different backgrounds
confirmed that members of both Muslim and Christian communities were currently accumulating
weapons, which they receive by different means, including from abroad. This is indeed alarming
and sounds like a warning which must be heeded.
The Government’s reaction
87.
The most striking aspect of this violence is the way the authorities responded to it.
According to the majority of the reports submitted to the Special Rapporteur, the authorities in
most cases did not initiate the mechanisms designed to prosecute the offenders and compensate
the victims. Despite efforts, including numerous requests, to secure information, the Special
Rapporteur has not received figures or other factual information on prosecutions initiated after
the riots and remedies provided to the victims. On numerous occasions, the Special Rapporteur
unsuccessfully tried to obtain from government officials copies of reports of commissions of
inquiry that had been established by the Government to investigate the causes and circumstances
of some of the riots.
88.
On the contrary, the Special Rapporteur’s interlocutors, including at the highest official
level, claimed that the identification of the instigators of the riots as well as the assessment of
damages suffered by the victims21 were particularly arduous. It was argued that rather than
prosecution and punishment, the promotion of peace and reconciliation was the authorities’
priority.