THE CONTRIBUTION OF NGOS TO CERD’S WORK
must be verified whether a potential communication
complies with the conditions set forth under Article 14
(see following sections). The consultation of the Rules of
Procedure40 established by CERD may also be useful for
this purpose.
How to write a communication:
Who can file a communication?
The letter should include information on:
Preparation of a communication:
● the name, address, age and occupation of the author
and verification of their identity;
● the name(s) of the state party or states parties against
which the communication is directed;
● the object of the communication;
● the provision or provisions of the Convention alleged
to have been violated;
● the facts of the claim;
● steps taken by the author to exhaust domestic remedies, including pertinent documents; and,
● the extent to which the same matter is being examined
under another procedure of international investigation
or settlement (Rule 84.1.a—g).
● Those individuals or groups of individuals who are
subject to the jurisdiction of a state party which has
recognized the competence of the Committee under
Article 14 can file a communication (Rule 91.a). Under
this rule, non-nationals or non-residents of the state
concerned can also submit a petition provided that they
have been victims of discrimination in that state.
● A communication must not be anonymous (Rule 91.a).
● Normally, only the individual concerned or their relatives or designated representatives can submit a communication. However, in exceptional cases, the Committee may accept a communication submitted by others on behalf of an alleged victim when it appears that
the victim is unable to submit the communication
themselves and the author of the communication justifies their acting on the victim s behalf (Rule 91.b).
● The Committee can only receive petitions from those
claiming to be victims of a violation of any of the
rights set forth in the Convention (Rule 81), meaning
that a violation of human rights beyond the scope of
ICERD cannot be considered by the Committee.
Exhaustion of domestic remedies:
● The individual must have exhausted all available
domestic remedies, including, when applicable, the
use of the national legal body established by paragraph 2 of Article 14. However, this shall not be the
rule where the application of the remedies is unreasonably prolonged41 (Rule 91.e). Furthermore, the
Committee has established that this rule applies only
to the extent that those remedies: i) are considered an
adequate avenue of redress, and ii) have any prospect
of success.42 In other words, where domestic remedies
are ineffective and a priori of no avail, the rule of
exhaustion of these remedies does not apply.
● The Communication must normally be submitted
within six months after all available domestic remedies have been exhausted (Rule 91.f).
The communication must be compatible with the provisions of the Convention (Rule 91.c) and must not contain
abusive language.
A model communication is to be found in Annexe III.
The communication has been sent — what will happen
to it?
The examination of the communication shall be held in
closed meetings (Rule 88).
Pre-admissibility stage:
● It may be that the information provided to the Committee is not sufficient to get a complete picture of the
situation and more clarification or information may be
asked for within an appropriate time limit (Rule 84.2).
● A communication may not be declared admissible
unless the State Party has received the text of the
communication and has been given an opportunity to
furnish further information (Rule 92.3). If the deadline fixed by the Committee for the submission of
such additional information is not kept by the State
Party concerned, the Committee may decide that the
communication is admissible in the light of the available information (Rule 92.6).
Consideration of communications on their merits:
● If all the formal requirements are met and the communication is admissible, it will be considered on its
merits. The Committee shall transmit, confidentially,
through the Secretary-General, the text of the com-
ICERD: A GUIDE FOR NON-GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS
19