UN Forum on Minority Issues
Intervention by Annie Namala, Director,
Centre for Programming Inclusion and Equity, New Delhi, India
annie.namala@gmail.com
On 16th Dec. 08
Madam Chair person, Prof. McDougal, members and friends,
EQUAL ACCESS TO QUALITY EDUCATION FOR MINORITIES
1. Non Discrimination
I thank you for this opportunity to place before you the concerns of discrimination
arising out of untouchability and caste practices against Dalit children in their
schooling process. For many Dalit children, so far protected within their segregated
habitations school becomes the first systematic instruction and experience on caste
bias. Discrimination of Dalit children is compounded by the belief and practices of
untouchability in India.
Non discrimination needs to be ensured at two levels:
a. Non discrimination in the provision of education by the state
b. Non discrimination in the process of schooling
In the context of Dalit students we see that both these are being violated and there is
no effective state mechanism to address them.
Discrimination in the state provisioning accounts on the following counts:
In the first case state itself promotes differential education through its many
policies – we have Alternate and Innovative Education (A&IE) Programme
where the state allocates about $25/year/child, regular government schooling
where the budget per child per year works out to about $60 and special
residential schools where the budget allocation per child is about
$300-400/child/year.
The state also does not regulate the private education where costs are
prohibitory for poor and minority students.
Discrimination in the process of schooling:
The caste system continues to be the basis of larger social norms and practices in
India. The norms of hierarchy, untouchability and exclusion of Dalits in society are
reflected in the school by the untouchability practices of dominant caste children,
teachers and society on Dalit children.
Dominant caste children refuse to sit, play or eat with Dalit children
They humiliate and physically abuse Dalit children
They do not share or build friendship with Dalit children