A/HRC/17/33/Add.4
26.
The Special Rapporteur was informed of several laws that prohibit discrimination
and make it an aggravating circumstance for the purpose of sentencing, such as the Unfair
Discrimination Act (2000). He also noted initiatives taken by various authorities, such as
the social dialogue on the promotion of tolerance and diversity, an initiative developed by
the Department of Home Affairs, and the parliamentary task teams on migration,
xenophobia and refugees, formed by the Portfolio Committee of Home Affairs and
comprising elected representatives from the National Assembly, which have engaged in the
promotion of the economic, justice and human rights of migrants and marginalized
communities.
27.
The Special Rapporteur was informed that a hate crime bill was currently being
prepared by the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development, in charge of
drafting bills proposed by the Government. The bill would strengthen the measures already
contained in the Constitution and other applicable laws to address violence against foreign
nationals (including asylum-seekers and refugees), and would expressly criminalize
violence committed against individuals or their property on the basis of a person’s race,
nationality, religion, ethnicity, sexual orientation or gender identity (“hate crime”). This
would follow the introduction in 2009of a law combating human trafficking, currently
tabled in Parliament. In the meantime, plans for a potential law against smuggling are still
being prepared.
C.
Initiative to regularize Zimbabwean nationals
28.
The Special Rapporteur was informed of a recent initiative to allow the
regularization of Zimbabwean nationals, which had been extended together with a
moratorium on repatriations and plans to consider such an initiative to other neighbouring
countries. On 3 April 2009, the Department of Home Affairs announced its intention to
grant Zimbabweans in South Africa a 12-month “special dispensation permit” on the basis
of the Immigration Act, section 31 (2)(b). The permit grants the right to legally live and
work in the country. As complementary measures, a moratorium on deportations and a 90day free visa for Zimbabweans entering South Africa were brought in in May 2009.
29.
The Special Rapporteur was able to witness the effects of this initiative first-hand at
the Beitbridge border crossing in Musina. The regularization of Zimbabwean migration is
consistent with internationally agreed policies on managing migration and has been
presented as one of the key goals of the current administration.
30.
The Special Rapporteur is of the opinion that the set of policies regularizing
movement between South Africa and Zimbabwe is a positive shift towards a more rational,
coherent and regionally beneficial approach to migration management. He noted that
previous approaches to managing Zimbabwean migration (including the asylum system and
widespread arrest and detention) did not address the nature or scale of movement, and thus
resulted in high levels of irregular migration, rights abuses and negative consequences for
South Africa.
31.
The introduction of special temporary permits to manage complex mixed migration
is increasingly common internationally. South Africa should receive recognition and
support for adopting this policy, given the widespread interest in supporting regional
stability and Zimbabwean reconstruction. Regularizing movement between South Africa
and Zimbabwe will help to achieve the development goals of the Southern Africa region by
facilitating efforts to combat corruption, protect labour standards, improve the economy and
fight crime. While the free visa and special dispensation permit is insufficient to achieve
these broader policy aims on its own, these challenges would be much more difficult to
tackle without the effective implementation of these policies.
9