clear racial dimension to the detriment of the African American population. Members of the
Muhamasheen minority in Yemen have often been displaced into open spaces or the edges of
towns, making their access to resources, such as shelter, water or medical emergency assistance,
even more difficult. And this list could be continued.
Unfortunately, the lack of readily accurate disaggregated data hinders much needed analysis. There
are a number of reasons for this. First of all, there is a likely reluctance of minorities displaced or
affected by crises to identify themselves as such for fear of further discrimination or violence.
Furthermore, States may be unwilling to collect such data, since they may not recognize the affected
minority group members as citizens, or their minority status, or do not want to draw attention to
specific difficulties faced by members of their societies. Humanitarian agencies tend to disaggregate
data mainly by sex and age, and rarely address other categories including minority status or special
needs. Therefore, I reiterate the crucial importance of the collection of data disaggregated by
ethnicity, religion and language to adequately map affected groups in humanitarian crises and natural
disasters and that data collection programmes should allow for diverse forms of self-identification
and comply with international standards regarding the right to privacy.
There are specific challenges facing minorities affected by humanitarian crises, including the situation
of particularly vulnerable groups, such as minority women and girls, which I will briefly introduce
here in four points:
1. Threats to existence: Minorities affected by crises and disasters may be specifically targeted
and may be at particular risk with regard to their physical safety and security both during
crises and in their aftermath, including violence and xenophobic attacks against them. In
some cases, the physical integrity of minorities can even be a key aspect of the conflict and
amounting to mass atrocity crimes. They may also experience particular restrictions on their
freedom of movement during conflict and humanitarian crises, as well as intimidation,
discrimination or even violence against them when trying to flee.
2. Particular challenges in accessing basic services: Due to discrimination and marginalization,
minorities who are affected by crises and disasters often lack proper access to water and
sanitation, adequate food, and other services. This may be compounded by a lack of
adequate documentation, which may impede access to humanitarian assistance including a
range of public services during crises such as health care, education, housing and
employment programs, as well as social integration.
3. Housing, land and property rights: Often clearly linked to the question of documentation,
minorities may not have official papers to prove their land rights. Moreover, land often has a
special meaning for minority communities, as some groups have a particular attachment to
their land or as their whole culture may rely on land.
4. Return and the search for durable solutions: Return always needs to be voluntary, and
carried out in safety and dignity in participation and consultation with the affected
communities who are often minorities. Where deportations take place without consent,
minorities may face numerous obstacles to their basic human rights. In some cases, the loss
of the temporary protection status in host countries and the forced repatriation to their
countries of origin, coupled with the lack of adequate policies for the integration of
returnees, have resulted in minority communities being forced to a circle of continuous
migration. Minorities may face particular obstacles, if they fled owing to violence
perpetrated against them because of their minority status and the root conditions of that