A/79/160
the green transition, as Governments and foreign investors assume that their lands are
empty. Wind and solar farms and the mining of energy transition minerals are imposed
on mobile Peoples’ lands without their consent, such as the mega hydropower dams
in Ethiopia 83 and the Olkaria Geothermal and Lake Turkana wind power projects in
Kenya, 84 the Alcazar Energy solar photovoltaic farm in Jordan 85 and the Zarafshan
wind power plant in Uzbekistan. 86 In Norway, litigation is under way and tensions are
rising over new wind power and mining projects on Sami territories, 87 despite the
Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination urging the Government to
stop the construction of wind farms, and a 2021 finding of the Supreme Court that the
Government violated Sami rights by permitting wind farms. 88 In his report on green
finance, the Special Rapporteur further warned of the risk of harm caused by
unregulated carbon markets on Indigenous Peoples’ rights. In Colombia, recently
contacted Nükak people signed a 100-year carbon credit contract with exclusivity and
irrevocability clauses favouring a private company, without fully understanding its
implications and lacking institutional support. 89
40. Exclusionary forms of conservation continue to be forced on mobile Indigenous
Peoples, leading to the loss of access to lands, territories, resources and marine areas,
involuntary resettlement, poverty and cultural loss. “Fortress conservation” principles
assume that Indigenous Peoples are incapable of caring for and protecting lands and
waters and therefore cause biodiversity loss and environmental degradation. 90 To the
contrary, studies show that Indigenous Peoples are the best conservators of nature. 91
For example, the use of sea and coastal resources practised by the Moken sea people
of Myanmar and Thailand has prevented environmental degradation. They move
between seas and islands and are not confined to specific jurisdictions or citizenships.
41. In Nepal, mobility is a distinct aspect of the Chepang Indigenous Peoples ’
identity. They depend on common property and solely live from the lands, forests and
waterways that surround them. In 1971, the Chitwan National Park was established
on Chepang lands without their free, prior and informed consent. Since then, they
have been subjected to forced evictions, the destruction of their homes, ill -treatment
and torture. 92
42. More than 6,000 Batwa hunter-gatherers have been evicted from their lands by
the creation of the Kahuzi-Biega National Park in the Democratic Republic of Congo,
without warning, compensation, reparations or resettlement options. They live as
squatters depending on non-Batwa host communities. 93 Their case is pending before
the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights. 94
43. In the United Republic of Tanzania, over 45 per cent of lands are State-owned
conservation areas, including the Ngorongoro Conservation Area, which attract over
600,000 tourists annually. A recent legal change prohibits human settlement in
__________________
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
14/28
Communication No. ETH 3/2011.
Mainyoito Pastoralists Integrated Development Organization submission.
Oxford University Collective for Pastoralist and Nomadic People submission.
Ibid.
Sami Parliament of Norway submission.
International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs, “Sami activists demand removal of wind
turbines in Fosen”, 14 October 2023.
See https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/documents/issues/indigenouspeoples/sr/statements/
20240315-sr-ipeoples-oem-statement-colombia.pdf.
Sonam Mahalwal and Asmita Kabra, “The slow violence of fortress conservation creates conditions
for socially unjust ‘voluntary’ relocation”, Biological Conservation, vol. 286 (October 2023).
Siham Drissi, “Indigenous Peoples and the nature they protect”, United Nations Environment
Programme, 8 June 2020.
Communication No. NPL 3/2020.
Communication No. COD 1/2018.
Minority Rights Group and others, joint submission.
24-13045