A/HRC/4/19/Add.2
page 23
Switzerland.37 The absence of this essential measuring tool makes it difficult to assess the
phenomenon and limits the effectiveness of even sporadic policies, programmes and initiatives to
combat racism. Moreover, since statistics are not standardized among the cantons, whatever data
are available, particularly data on crime, are difficult to interpret.
78.
Through the diversity of situations and policies, the Special Rapporteur noted the impact
of the distinctive nature of the federal structure, the powers and prerogatives of the cantons and
the democratic tradition of popular votes on the recognition and treatment of questions relating
to racism and xenophobia. It would appear, therefore, that the question of racism, racial
discrimination and xenophobia has not been the subject of a comprehensive and coherent
approach or a resolute and credible national political programme.
79.
The Special Rapporteur is particularly alarmed at the possibility that, owing to their
electoral impact, racist and xenophobic political platforms will spread in the future,
bearing in mind the degree of resistance to cultural diversity in the light of the increasing
multiculturalization, particularly as a result of non-European immigration, of Swiss society. In
this regard, there are already signs, particularly in the context of the widespread tendency in
Europe to associate Islam with terrorism, that one of the prime targets of these platforms will be
the presence of Muslims in Switzerland.
80.
During his visit, the Special Rapporteur spoke at length with his interlocutors concerning
integration measures and programmes. He noted that the positive aspects of some of these
programmes are handicapped by two political and cultural factors in Switzerland: (a) at the
political level, by ideological hostility to integration, reflected in the political platforms of
parties, such as the Swiss People’s Party/Centre Democratic Union, which are members of the
Government; and (b) at the cultural level, by the rejection of cultural diversity, which takes the
form of refusing to acknowledge the cultural specificity of immigrant minorities, particularly
non-European minorities, which are suspected of threatening “national identity” and are enjoined
to “adapt to national values”, thereby depriving such minorities of any opportunity to make
cultural contributions to and enrich Swiss society.
81.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes the commitment, in the context of Switzerland’s
participatory democracy, of associations and civil society, including churches, to combating
racism in Switzerland. However, he notes with concern the current political and legal trend,
demonstrated by the most recent vote, towards abolishing measures to defend and protect
victims.
82.
The Special Rapporteur is particularly alarmed at the situation, often extremely
precarious, of asylum-seekers whose applications have not been considered for formal reasons,
and at the Government’s policy - characterized by criminalization, suspicion and rejection -
37
The Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination requested such information from
Switzerland in 2002: “The Committee requests information about the legislation in force
prohibiting racial discrimination within the private sector in fields such as employment, housing,
education, health and access to public places.” (CERD/C/60/CO/14, para. 16).