A/HRC/4/19/Add.2
page 15
47.
During the Special Rapporteur’s discussions with various cantonal and federal
departments, in particular the Federal Office for Migration and the departments of justice and
police, it was pointed out that crime in Switzerland was perpetrated mainly by foreigners,
particularly asylum-seekers, that 90 per cent of requests for asylum do not meet admissibility
criteria, and that it would therefore be necessary to adopt measures to distinguish “bad”
asylum-seekers from “good” ones. Moreover, in a letter to the Special Rapporteur, the Federal
Office for Migration, states that “the return of individuals to certain countries of origin is often
very difficult, or even impossible, when the foreigner concerned chooses not to cooperate with
the authorities. Such problems are currently encountered by a large number of persons from
African countries. For this reason, they are likely to be subjected to coercive measures and are
comparatively often placed in detention pending deportation. However, this state of affairs does
not have any racial connotations”.
48.
The delegates for integration who met with the Special Rapporteur stressed the
importance of the policy for promoting the integration of foreigners, and noting in this regard
that foreigners should be allowed to vote and stand for election.
49.
The Special Rapporteur noted with interest the initiatives undertaken by certain cantonal
police forces, particularity in Basel City, where the police authorities and associations
representing black communities have begun meetings for dialogue and exchange of views.
Such exchanges have reportedly improved reciprocal knowledge, reduced prejudice and
misunderstandings, and fostered better contacts between the police and these communities. The
Special Rapporteur notes that the encouragement of similar intercultural dialogues is one way to
prevent the deterioration of social relations and to avoid misunderstandings and errors arising
from ignorance and lack of comprehension of others.
50.
In Basel, the Special Rapporteur visited a deportation centre and a centre for registering
applicants at the border. He noted that, while almost all detainees in this deportation centre were
black, there were few blacks in the registration centre. According to the explanation given by
the authorities, “the high proportion of Africans in the Basel deportation centre can be explained
by an enforcement problem. Persons whose countries have concluded bilateral return
agreements or who are considered to be willing to cooperate cannot be held in deportation
centres. Bilateral return agreements provide for material assistance for the return, which gives
individuals an incentive to return to their countries without resistance; there are no such
agreements with African countries. This is why a high number of Africans are held in
deportation centres”. This explanation is contained in a letter from the Service for Combating
Racism, entitled “Additional information on the subject of remedies”, which was sent to the
Special Rapporteur following his visit.
III. ANALYSIS OF THE SITUATION BY OTHER ACTORS
A. Civil society
51.
The Special Rapporteur met with various components of civil society, including
representatives of foreign communities, religious communities, NGOs, associations,
asylum-seekers, trade unions and employers. He therefore had an opportunity to hear real-life