A/HRC/35/25
pressure and impetus to the need to balance labour supply and demand,3 clearly
contradicting the common conception that migrants are “job stealers”.
22.
Against the backdrop of a poor economic climate, the rise in nationalist populist
parties and the tragic terrorist attacks around the world, xenophobia and hate speech have
increased, causing a significant upward trend in negative perceptions of migrants and
creating a stumbling block in the development of more efficient evidence- and human
rights-based policies.
23.
The use of appropriate language and studies, the presentation of facts and policies
that favour diversity and the inclusion of migrants are key to facilitating the integration of
migrants and their contribution to development and to reducing negative populist
representations of migrants. States therefore need to develop a long-term, human rightsbased strategic vision and narrative on mobility and diversity that will give meaning,
coherence and direction to current and future action.
24.
A human rights-based approach would have a positive impact on the public
discourse and facilitate the integration of migrants into society by changing the general
perception of migration as being a burden and expense to being a shared responsibility and
valuable investment.
Migration supports development and prosperity at the national, regional
and global levels
25.
Migrants are drivers and enablers of development, contributing to economic growth
wherever they go. Studies show that immigration has a minimal impact on unemployment
among residents in host countries and a positive overall impact on employment generation
and investment.4 Increasing evidence suggests that migrants contribute more in direct and
indirect taxes than they consume in government benefits.5 In 2015, migrants sent
approximately $601 billion in remittances, some $441 billion of which developing
countries are estimated to have received, nearly three times the amount of official
development assistance.6
26.
Economic research also demonstrates that migrants complement rather than compete
with citizens, therefore generating greater overall productivity within the economy.7 In a
study,8 the impact of the global recession was shown to decrease but not eradicate this
positive phenomenon, disproving the argument that an economic downturn justifies
repressive policies against migrants. Although some nationals may be displaced by
migrants in small and other specific labour markets, it is better to address such marginal
consequences through retraining policies rather than by trying to curb migration.
27.
Although the economic incentives to migrate are diverse and, for many, very strong,
they are constantly evaluated and scrutinized by potential migrants. It is true that most
migrants try to go to countries where there are jobs and where they can start integrating into
society and creating a future for themselves and their families. It is equally true that prime
destination countries have jobs available for migrants in the official or underground labour
3
4
5
6
7
8
6
Ernst and Young, “Tracking global trends: how six key developments are shaping the business world”
(2011). Available from https://issuu.com/ezra1110/docs/tracking_global_trends/32.
See Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, International Migration Outlook
2013.
OHCHR, The economic, social and cultural rights of migrants in an irregular situation,
(New York and Geneva, 2014), p. 99.
See World Bank, Migration and Remittances Factbook 2016.
David Card, “The impact of the Mariel boatlift on the Miami labour market”, Industrial and Labour
Relations Review, vol. 43, No. 2 (January 1990), pp. 245-257; Mette Foged and Giovanni Peri,
“Immigrants’ effect on native workers: new analysis on longitudinal data”, Institute for the Study of
Labour discussion paper No. 8961, 2015; Andri Chassamboulli and Giovanni Peri, “The labour
market effects of reducing the number of illegal immigrants”, Review of Economic Dynamics, vol. 18,
No. 4 (October 2015).
Francesco D’Amuri and Giovanni Peri, “Immigration, jobs and employment protection: evidence
from Europe before and during the Great Recession”, Bank of Italy working paper No. 886, 2012.