A/HRC/35/41/Add.1
the medical personnel refused to treat her for three days and only reacted when the patient
was in agonizing pain. The absence of equipment and medication was also raised. The
Ombudsperson, for example, reported that a field visit late in 2015 to several departments
mostly inhabited by indigenous peoples in the Chaco province revealed serious
impediments in gaining access to secondary health centres, due to the limited availability of
ambulances, qualified doctors and basic medical supplies and medication to treat common
affections. The investigation also highlighted the total absence of an intercultural
perspective in public health policies.12
35.
It should be noted that the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF), in its 2015
country report on Argentina, underscored that between 1990 and 2014 child mortality
among indigenous children aged under 5 years had stagnated at three times the national
average, which itself had decreased over the same period.13 Recently, an emerging trend of
possible high incidence of suicide among indigenous young people was to be investigated
by the organization.
36.
A research published in 2013 by the University of Buenos Aires presented alarming
data regarding the malnutrition of indigenous children in the province of Salta. The study,
carried out from June to August 2011 in 74 communities, showed a significant prevalence
of chronic malnourishment among indigenous children of up to 62.4 per cent of 1 to 4-yearolds, and 37.5 per cent, of those aged under 1 year. In total, 50 per cent of indigenous
children aged under 1 year and 70.8 per cent of those aged 1 to 4 suffered from some type
of nutritional deficit. The Special Rapporteur on the rights of indigenous peoples had
already reported in 2012 concerns about the situation in the Chaco province, which was
ordered by the National Supreme Court to take a series of actions to ensure that the
inhabitants of the region receive health care and adequate food. Unfortunately, cases of
death linked to malnutrition of indigenous children were again reported both in Chaco and
Salta in 2015.
37.
While visiting the northern provinces of Salta and Formosa, recurring complaints
were received about access to education, namely, the absence of adequate proximity
educational facilities, the absence of qualified teachers to implement the bilingual
intercultural education enshrined in the Constitution, the high level of school dropout or
even instances where children had passed a class without having really achieved the
required level of learning. Furthermore, situations of stigmatization and isolation of
indigenous children in mixed schools were reported, with little effort from educators to
foster a culture of acceptance, mutual respect and understanding among students. The
Special Rapporteur notes with grave concern the absence of qualified teachers from
indigenous communities nationwide, which is a serious obstacle to the implementation of
bilingual intercultural education. In general, teachers receive very little training on
intercultural education and indigenous themes. Failure to implement an intercultural
bilingual education has de facto excluded a significant number of indigenous children from
having access to adequate education.
38.
Moreover, the large differences between the availability of adequate educational
facilities in urban versus rural areas disproportionally affect indigenous children. For
example, in Salta, the local Ministry of Education noted that until very recently there had
been no secondary schools in rural areas. In October 2013, the Ombudsperson was called to
visit a community in the province of Salta, where it found that the infrastructures of the
local school were in clear violation of the rights of more than 500 children, mostly
indigenous. The only response received was from the provincial Ministry of Education,
which mentioned that a refurbishment project would be introduced in the 2015 budget
proposal. This example, among many similar ones, is telling of the little commitment by the
various institutions to prioritize actions to immediately stop the violations endured by
indigenous peoples, including children.
12
13
See Defensor del Pueblo de la Nación, Informe Anual 2015 (Buenos Aires, 2015), p. 44. Available
from www.dpn.gob.ar/documentos/anuales/ianual2015.pdf.
See UNICEF, “Informe Anual de Actividades, Argentina, 2015”, p. 18. Available from
www.unicef.org/argentina/spanish/pfp_informeAnaul2016.pdf.
9