Guidelines on the use of Minority Languages in the Broadcast Media 10) Promotion of Languages In regulating the use of language in the broadcast media, States may promote the use of selected languages. Measures to promote one or more language(s) should not restrict the use of other languages. States may not prohibit the use of any language in the broadcast media. Measures to promote any language in broadcast media should not impair the enjoyment of the rights of persons belonging to national minorities. 11) Proportionality of Regulation Any regulation, whether prescriptive or proscriptive, must pursue a legitimate aim and be proportionate to that aim. When assessing the proportionality of any regulation, specific factors concerning the nature of the media and wider social environment should be considered. Such factors include: • The nature and objectives of the measure, including its potential to contribute to the quality and balance of programming, in pursuit of the protection and promotion of freedom of expression, cultural and linguistic diversity, and the maintenance and development of cultural identity. • The existing political, social and religious context, including cultural and linguistic diversity, structures of governance, and regional characteristics. • The number, variety, geographical reach, character, function and languages of available broadcasting services – whether public, private or foreign – at all levels (national, regional and local). The financial costs to the audience of the various services, technical possibilities for reception and the quantity as well as the quality of broadcasting, both in terms of the scheduling of slots and the type of programming, are all relevant considerations. • The rights, needs, expressed desires and nature of the audience(s) affected, including their numerical size and geographical concentration, at each level (national, regional and local). 9

Select target paragraph3