A/HRC/42/59
suspension according to a recent study by the United States Department of Education
Office for Civil Rights. The environment for people of African descent in North America
had become extremely stressful, which had resulted in a higher rate of post-traumatic stress
disorder in the African-American community compared with their white counterparts.
39.
Yeshimabeit Milner, co-founder of Data for Black Lives, spoke on the vital role of
data with regard to the safety and security of people of African descent. Data had recently
exposed a disturbing trend in which children of African-American descent were three times
more likely to die before their first birthday than white children. Inadequate education and
training provided by hospitals to young mothers of African descent was responsible for that
disparity. That trend could not have been identified if data on the situation of children of
African descent born in the United States had not been collected and analysed. Another
recent trend that was severely disadvantageous for people of African descent was for
governments to rely on automated algorithms as a tool to generate solutions. The objective
function of those algorithms incorporated the biases that existed as a result of historical
injustices and the values of the programmers. Those biases then translated into algorithms
that exhibited racial discrimination.
40.
Mr. Murillo Martínez addressed the growing challenges in the use of artificial
intelligence with regard to racial discrimination against people of African descent. He
provided several examples of concerns around the ethics and governance of artificial
intelligence and of bias in technological advances, such as facial recognition, and software
used in the criminal justice sector in certain countries. At its next session, the Committee on
the Elimination of Racial Discrimination would be debating a draft general
recommendation on racial profiling, which would examine ethical aspects of cybersecurity
and would seek to provide guidelines to prevent and sanction racial bias in artificial
intelligence. In relation to the proposed general recommendation, he called for submissions
to the Committee, among others, of the criteria that companies should apply in preventing
racial bias in the programming and use of algorithms; notable examples of artificial
intelligence-related racial discrimination; examples of research and best practice in the
prevention of or response to racial bias stemming from artificial intelligence; and ethical
aspects of machine learning and relevant criteria to ensure understanding and transparency
in the programming process pertaining to issues of race.
41.
During the interactive discussion, the representative of the United Kingdom
commented on artificial intelligence and algorithmic bias and the risks they presented
within the criminal justice system. Speakers asked if there were any other countries that
could be learned from with respect to algorithmic bias. Mr. Murillo Martínez noted that
Germany had had a successful experience in eliminating racial bias in algorithms. In
Germany, there were generalized measures of training algorithms so that the bias could be
corrected to avoid harmful consequences. A main challenge was the independence of
algorithms after they might have been programmed to express racial bias. Mr. Sunga asked
Ms. Milner to provide more information regarding the 2020 United States Census and how
the census could be reconfigured better. Ms. Milner stated that since it was the first census
that would be fully online, there were now issues around security and privacy that had to be
taken into account. Moreover, she discussed the need to mobilize people to take part in the
census. A civil society representative asked Ms. Milner to provide more information about
infant mortality. Ms. Milner said that research suggested that the aggressive targeting of
black mothers by the infant formula industry and the overuse of caesarean sections might
contribute to higher infant mortality for black infants. The use of midwives or doulas and
more natural methods for childbirth and child-rearing might mitigate the disparity. In
response to a question from the representative of Haiti on the role of the church in seeking
racial justice, Ms. Thompson stated that an increasing number of African Americans were
leaving the church – often to discover ancestral religious practices – while there remained
many young leaders in the church who were agitating for racial justice and often received
less publicity. She also acknowledged that the church was not exempt from the past, and
that it had amassed a lot of wealth from enslavement.
42.
The fifth panel focused on the mapping of people of African descent in Asia and
other parts of the world. The first speaker, Mr. Sunga, shared the challenges due to the lack
of data availability in the Asian region. He strongly urged Asian States to do more with
10