A/HRC/4/24/Add.3
page 8
Debt bondage
20.
Migrant domestic workers commonly become heavily indebted trying to pay exorbitant,
unregulated recruitment-agency fees, which are either paid through long-term salary deductions
or by a large fee paid up front to the local recruiter - often financed through loans with high
interest rates. In Singapore and Hong Kong, deductions of 8-10 months’ salary on a
2-year contract are common. Most domestic workers pay up front fees by borrowing money
from their agent, village moneylenders, family, or friends, often at usurious interest rates.
Exorbitant initial fees and long debt repayment periods place migrant workers in a highly
vulnerable position. Migrant domestic workers feel enormous pressure to keep working as long
as they can in order to repay their debt and start earning a salary, even when faced with
intolerable situations.
21.
Employment agents similarly have a strong interest in workers remaining in a job until
they have repaid their debt, and thus are less likely to help workers out of abusive situations.
Sometimes they may be the first to condemn domestic workers to isolation by stripping them of
contact information and supporting employer restrictions on their movements and their ability to
communicate. Sometimes agents are directly responsible for abuse. Many of the female migrant
domestic workers interviewed had experienced severe abuse at the hands of Indonesian
employment agents. These abuses included confiscation of passports and/or personal
belongings, as well as threats, beatings and other physical abuse.
22.
Already in debt, migrant workers typically face further fees and salary deductions if they
attempt to transfer to another employer or seek to return to their home country before their
employment contract expires.
Labour-related abuses
23.
NGOs and Indonesian embassies/consulates abroad have reported that unpaid wages,
long working hours without rest days and forced confinement at the workplace are among the
most common complaints made by female migrant workers. Domestic workers are excluded
from the labour laws of most countries, leaving them at particularly high risk of exploitation with
few avenues for seeking redress.
24.
Several factors contribute to the further isolation of female migrant domestic workers,
including financial hardship, limited access to assistance, and the confiscation of passports by the
employer and/or the labour agency.11 This last practice in particular creates a strong power
imbalance. The denial of freedom of movement dramatically increases the vulnerability of
domestic workers to exploitation, forced labour, intimidation and sexual abuse. Employers
typically impose severe restrictions on the ability of domestic workers to communicate with the
outside world, and are even known to prevent domestic workers from talking to neighbours or
11
Ibid., for more information, see the Human Rights Watch series of reports on Indonesian
domestic workers available at http://hrw.org/campaigns/women/2006/domestic_workers/
reports.htm.