to pay attention to those who are typically
marginalised and whose issues would not
necessarily be voiced either by themselves, or
by the State authorities or other residents on
their behalf.
When to use the Vulnerable Groups List during
the “Programme/Project Cycle”
To ensure that information gathered is relevant to human rights indicators or couched
in the human rights framework.
2) During Policy and Programming development
To ensure that the needs of men and women
are taken into account in the process of design
of the project/programme/policy at the local
level.
3) Monitoring and Evaluation stages: if new
challenges arise, for example during the
“reflective praxis”, this tool will help as a background document for human rights related
questions with regard to social inclusion and
non-discrimination issues
How to use the Vulnerable Groups List
Assessment teams/users could use the list
as a reference for the types of questions to
be asked in identifying the most vulnerable
groups and relevant municipal actors.
This list does not claim to be exhaustive and
is intended to be a living instrument that
teams can adapt according to experience and
relevance in the field. As a result, users may
use it as a guideline, rather than as a rigid
tool. Similar questions may also be asked of
other groups under each sector depending
on what emerges as a priority in the municipality/sector assessed. Assessment teams/
researchers are encouraged to add their own
questions/comments and, where necessary,
go that one step further to ask, ‘why?’
When answering the questions in the list, one
needs to explain how such conclusions were
reached and assessed (e.g. is this an impression formed during the assessment visit?
Was information gathered from NGOs or the
general public? Was there any focus group discussion conducted?). References and sources
for answers need to be provided.
1) This tool will help you to ask relevant
questions during the situation and problem
analysis
Vulnerability assessment list for Roma
Note: The HRBA and Gender in Local Governance
Toolkit (2007) also includes vulnerability assessments for: national minorities, migrant workers,
refugees and asylum seekers.
Marginalisation / Discrimination
Is there political, social and/or economical
discrimination against Roma communities?
Have the authorities taken measures to
improve the relations between Roma communities and non-Roma communities, with a
view to promoting tolerance and overcoming
prejudices and negative stereotypes on
both sides?
Status/identity
Are Roma people registered as “displaced
persons” or “refugees”? Do they have evidence
of that status?
Do the authorities respect the wishes of Roma
as to the designation they want to be given
and the group to which they want to belong?
Is there any disadvantage resulting from the
choice Roma make in that respect?
Chapter 8: Situation Analysis Tools
121