E/CN.4/1999/58
page 16
entirely adequate to satisfy the requirements of the religious public; (b) the
recent expansion of the Tibetan economy had provided many job opportunities
for Tibetans, especially young people, and had led to a reduction in the
number of people electing to join monastic communities; (c) since the 1990s,
preferential education policies in the Tibetan region had led young Tibetans
to study culture and science rather than enter monasteries. However, Tibetan
monks and nuns still accounted for 2 per cent of Tibet's population. The
reply stated that the Dalai Lama used religion (an example being the
designation of the Panchen Lama) to pursue separatist activities, of which the
great bulk of monks and nuns and religious believers in Tibet disapproved.
The reply denied the allegation that the child designated as Panchen Lama by
the Dalai Lama was being detained and the following explanation was given:
the security measures for the boy and his parents had been adopted at their
request following an abduction attempt by exiled Tibetan separatists. The
reply noted that Chadrel Rinpoche, Champa Chung and Samdrup (see
E/CN.4/1996/95, para. 40; E/CN.4/1997/91, para. 43 (e); E/CN.4/1998/6,
para. 73; A/52/477, para. 36) had been sentenced to prison terms for
imperilling the unity of the State and ethnic cohesiveness and damaging
stability and development in Tibet; it was noted that, as Chadrel and Champa
had infringed the State Secrets Law, it had been decided to hold the trial
in camera.
Cyprus
49.
It is alleged that, in the areas controlled by the Turkish Army, a
policy of intolerance and religious discrimination is directed against
non-Muslims and their religious property (more than 500 places of worship and
cemeteries desecrated and the Saint Makar Armenian monastery converted into a
hotel, etc.).
Egypt
50.
Professor Hassan Hanafi was allegedly declared an apostate by Al-Azhar
scholars because of his interpretations of Islam. One communication also
speaks of excesses committed by armed extremist groups - Al-Gihad and
Al-Gama'a al-Islamiya - against all segments of Egyptian society, and in
particular law enforcement officers, intellectuals and Copts. From May 1992
to December 1997, in the Provinces of Minya, Asyut and Qena, Upper Egypt,
several Copts were reportedly murdered by Al-Gama'a al-Islamiya because of
their Christian beliefs; in 1998, three Copts were allegedly executed. It is
also reported that Copts are victims of racketeering and that their churches
are attacked. According to another communication, in July 1998, security
forces in Maadi closed an unauthorized Coptic church. However, the procedure
for obtaining a construction or renovation permit is said to be so complicated
that such permits are virtually never granted.
51.
In connection with the Hanafi case, Egypt replied that statements made
by this Cairo University professor during a talk had been criticized by a
certain Al-Azhar Scholars' Association which had regarded them as a departure
from the Muslim religion. The Egyptian authorities pointed out that the
association in question was not legally empowered to review or assess research
into Muslim religious teachings, and that no measures had been taken by anyone
against Professor Hanafi. Egypt also referred to the facts in the Abu Zeid