A/CONF.189/PC.2/22
page 29
underlying this issue.108 In this connection, while it is perfectly legitimate for a State to consider
making an integrationist effort with the (or any one) official language, the concern to ensure
respect for the self-esteem of all the individuals comprising that State must also be taken into
account. Various forms of social behaviour of children and, later, of adults are contingent
thereon. What is likely to be the attitude of a child who does not believe in himself or is taught
to believe in the superiority of the language of the group to which he belongs (even if it is the
majority)? Education is thus the crucible for a civic attitude in society as a whole, whatever its
ethnic or religious make-up.
3. Lack or shortage of adequate resources
99.
The failure to supply adequate resources to provide an education meeting the various
aspirations for ensuring non-discrimination is a highly complex issue, objectively speaking,
in view of the financial difficulties experienced by educational systems throughout the
world, and particularly in the developing countries. In most of the countries surveyed by
Francesco Capotorti, secondary education is not provided in minority languages. The reasons
often given include a lack of funds, the unavailability of competent teaching staff and the desire
not to fragment the educational system or, indeed, to impair national unity.109
100. In this connection, consideration must be given only to cases where such an attitude is
based on discriminatory grounds and the shortage of funds affects the various ethnic and/or
religious groups unequally. Thus, for example, in some European countries,110 budget cut backs
and austerity policies affect educational programmes intended for the children of minorities or
emigrants (in particular, remedial classes). In this regard, the Committee on the Elimination of
Racial Discrimination recently had occasion to point out that “the situation of Roma is a subject
of particular concern since no improvements have been noted in the … low educational level
traditionally predominant among members of this minority”111 and recommended that “measures
of affirmative action should be adopted in favour of the Roma population, especially in the areas
of education and vocational training …”.112 In any event, it is only when such measures
(or rather such non-measures) have an excessive impact and consequences for the enjoyment of
the fundamental rights of a particular group that they may be described as prohibited
discrimination.
III. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
101. Many factors of widely varying impact and far from easy to understand exert a negative
influence, as we have seen, on education in relation to racial discrimination and religious
intolerance. These factors include historical circumstances, the social and economic conditions
of groups and minorities, their demographic distribution in the territory, their cultural
impoverishment, the prejudices of dominant groups, the status of the majority and minority
languages, the political will of the Government and of the groups themselves, the shortage of
resources and the lack of intercultural dialogue. It would certainly not be realistic to expect that
taking action on these factors could achieve the desired results immediately: some of them are
not, in fact, specific to education and would require major efforts by the State and the
international community, as well as considerable resources, which would not necessarily be
forthcoming at short notice; other factors might not require substantial resources but would need