A/HRC/23/46
100. The EU has entered into several readmission agreements with third countries,
facilitating the readmission of irregular migrants, including own nationals as well as third
country nationals. The Council has issued negotiating directives to the Commission for 19
countries, and so far 13 EU Readmission Agreements have entered into force. Readmission
clauses have been incorporated in agreements such as the European Neighbourhood Policy
and visa facilitation agreements. Most recently, an EU-Turkey readmission agreement was
initialled in 2012.
101. Furthermore, the ability for EU Member States to continue to conclude bilateral
readmission agreements is maintained in Protocol (no 23) to the Treaty on the Functioning
of the EU “on external relations of the Member States with regard to the crossing of
external borders”, as long as they respect EU law and other relevant international
agreements.
102. In the Stockholm Programme, the Council invited the Commission to present an
evaluation during 2010 of EU readmiss ion agreements and ongoing negotiations, and to
propose a mechanism to monitor the implementation of the agreements. On that basis, the
Council should define a renewed, coherent strategy on readmission. Thus, in February
2011, the Commission presented a Communication to the European Parliament and the
Council, aiming to evaluate the implementation of the EU Readmission agreements already
in force; assess the ongoing readmission negotiations; and provide recommendations for a
future EU readmission policy, including on monitoring mechanisms. The Communication
recommended that as a rule, future negotiating directives should not cover third country
nationals. Only in cases where there is a big potential risk of irregular migration transiting a
country’s territory to the EU due to its geographical location, should the third country
national clause be included, and only when appropriate incentives are offered. It further
recommended that NGOs and international organizations should participate, on a case-bycase basis, in the Joint Readmission Committees, which should work much more closely
with relevant actors on the ground in the third countries, including on the monitoring of the
treatment of third country nationals.
103. Section 4.3 of the Commission’s Communication deals with possible measures to
enhance human rights guarantees in EU Readmission Agreements, including enhancing the
access to international protection and legal remedies in practice; providing for suspension
clauses for persistent human rights violations in the third country concerned; giving
preference to voluntary departure; requiring compliance with human rights for the treatment
of third country nationals readmitted to a transit country; and setting up a post -return
monitoring mechanism in the countries of return.
104. In June 2011, the Justice and Home Affairs Council adopted conclusions defining
the EU strategy on readmission, stating, inter alia, that “combating illegal immigration is a
major migration policy goal of the European Union”. The Council considered that more
attention should be paid to the main countries of origin, but stated that it will continue, as a
general rule, incorporating clauses on the readmission of third country nationals. The
Council further stated that Joint Readmission Committees were to be considered as the
main tools for monitoring the implementation of EU Readmission Agreements.
D.
1.
Legal, institutional and policy framework with regard to asylum
The Common European Asylum System
105. Article 78(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union states that the
EU shall develop a common policy on asylum, subsidiary protection and temporary
protection with a view to offering appropriate status to any third-country national requiring
international protection and ensuring compliance with the principle of non-refoulement.
40