A/51/301
English
Page 9
C.
Comments of the Special Rapporteur
7.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes the clarifications provided by Germany and
Italy regarding the alleged incidents of racial discrimination which have been
brought to their attention. He congratulates both Governments for the measures
they have taken to punish the offenders and to improve, through appropriate
action, the situation regarding xenophobia and racial violence. The Special
Rapporteur, convinced and respectful of the rule of law based on the recognition
of the dignity of the human person, trusts in those two countries’ systems of
justice and encourages them to pursue their efforts to curb racism, racial
discrimination and xenophobia. He requests the Governments concerned to keep
him informed as to the outcome of the cases currently under consideration.
D.
Field missions
8.
In 1994 and 1995, the Special Rapporteur visited five countries (Brazil,
France, Germany, the United States of America and the United Kingdom of Great
Britain and Northern Ireland) in order to illustrate the various forms of racism
and racial discrimination through specific examples. It has been claimed that
the presence of several Western countries among those he visited was evidence of
bias on the part of the Special Rapporteur, despite his insistence on the fact
that racism and racial discrimination as defined in the International Convention
on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination exist throughout the
world. 3/ That also applies to xenophobia, one of the manifestations of racism.
The Special Rapporteur’s awareness of the universality of these matters is such
that he will not be influenced by motives other than concern for objectivity and
the wish to serve the cause of human rights. The joint consideration of the
situations in Germany, France and the United Kingdom, far from stigmatizing a
particular region, simply takes account of those States’ desire to place their
human rights policies in the context of the European Union. Also, attention was
focused first on the developed States because they are experiencing a resurgence
of manifestations of racism and xenophobia in those countries.
9.
It should be emphasized that the goodwill of the Governments of the
countries we visited made a major contribution to the successful fulfilment of
the mandate. Therefore, like the Commission on Human Rights, the General
Assembly should congratulate the Governments of Brazil, France, Germany, the
United States of America and the United Kingdom for having established a
dialogue with the Special Rapporteur and for having been attentive to his
recommendations.
10. In this context, it should be added that the Government of the United
States of America has transmitted to the Special Rapporteur detailed comments on
the mission report which he submitted to the Commission on Human Rights at its
fifty-first session (E/CN.4/1995/78/Add.1). Those comments, after translation,
have now been communicated to the Special Rapporteur who will present his
observations to the Commission at its fifty-third session.
11. Following consideration by the Commission on Human Rights at its fiftysecond session of the report of the Special Rapporteur on his mission in Brazil
(E/CN.4/1995/72/Add.1), that country’s representative expressed his Government’s
/...