Guidelines to Assist National Minority
Participation in the Electoral Process
Page: 16
certain circumstances make the critical difference between a party assuming and losing power. It will
also determine the level of representation of parties especially representative of minorities.
The choice then of the most appropriate system becomes a critical one. But, electoral systems alone
do not solve potential ethnic conflict. The electoral system must be viewed as one of a multiplicity of
interlocking mechanisms which, taken together, will have the effect of accommodating national
minorities and ensuring their effective participation in public life. By way of illustration, reserved
seats for a particular community may ensure them representation, but, unless the underlying processes
and mechanisms, such as funding, eligibility, training and education are provided, that representation
may have little influence.
Accordingly, while the electoral system may ensure minority representation in the legislature, there
remains no guarantee that the minority represented in the legislature will be accorded any material role
in the parliament or in government structures. Representation is often not enough. It needs to be
supported by other measures. For example in Parliament, the minority may be accorded key seats in
parliamentary committees that concern the interests of national minorities or special procedures may
be established to deal with minority vetoes in respect of minority issues. In government structures, the
proportional allocation of civil service positions may be a mechanism that may be considered to give
real meaning to minority participation in public life. These kinds of supporting measures all contribute
to turning what would otherwise be a formal minority of seats in Parliament into meaningful
participation of a national minority in public life. There may also be a perception of tokenism in an
allocation of seats to a national minority without those seats constituting a platform for a meaningful
influence on the decisions that affect that minority. That perception undermines the legitimacy of the
State’s measures to accommodate the minority, allowing ethnic entrepreneurs to attack and thereby
undermine the accommodation accorded to the minority by the State.
It is essential that the electoral system take account of displaced persons or refugees who may be
resident outside the country. This is particularly the case after serious ethnic conflict when refugees or
displaced persons may consist substantially of one communal group. In that event, a constituency
system may not be appropriate because of the difficulties associated with access to the constituency
either for the purpose of registration or voting.
It is also essential for an electoral system to take into account the existence of national minorities that
are, or may in the past have been, nomadic. The strict application of a constituency system may
effectively disenfranchise them. The establishment of an electoral district in the former Yugoslav
Republic of Macedonia to enable the election of a representative of the Roma community is an
example of a good practice. This district, Shuto Orizari, encompasses the largest concentration of
Roma in Europe.
External voting provisions should apply equally and should not have a detrimental effect on national
minority representation. If there are external voting provisions, national minority suffrage and
representation should be encouraged.
The manner and form in which statistics are compiled, or in which a national census takes place, is
important in that reliability, accuracy and fairness may affect issues of national minority representation
of how an electoral system can lead to lead to serious conflict is Lesotho. In the 1998 election the ruling party won 79 out of 80 constituencies
with only 60.5 percent of the votes. The post election violence, protesting the result, led to armed intervention by neighbouring States and the
establishment of an interim political authority charged with the responsibility of designing a new electoral system with elements of both a
constituency based system and proportional representation.