Guidelines to Assist National Minority
Participation in the Electoral Process
Page: 15
form a political party do not resort to violence or conflict with the rights of others, there should be no
impediment for them to associate in that manner.
B.
-
LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK
The right to freedom of association should be entrenched in the State’s Constitution and should not
permit legislative or executive restriction of that right except to the extent necessary in a
democratic society.
Any restrictions on the freedom of association should be prescribed in law. There should be no prior
consent necessary to establish an association although it is permissible for a State to require
associations to register for certain purposes, provided that the registration procedure does not in effect
make it difficult for associations to register and operate.
VII.
LUND RECOMMENDATION ON ELECTIONS: No. 9
“The electoral system should facilitate minority representation and influence.
•
Where minorities are concentrated territorially, single member districts may
provide sufficient minority representation;
•
Proportional representation systems, where a political party’s share in the
national vote is reflected in its share of the legislative seats, may assist in the
representation of minorities;
•
Some forms of preference voting, where voters rank candidates in order of
choice, may facilitate minority representation and promote inter-communal
co-operation;
•
Lower numerical thresholds for representation in the legislature may enhance
the inclusion of national minorities in governance.”
A.
CONTENT EXPLANATION
The basic premise of the guidelines under this paragraph is that States that have well designed
democratic political institutions are more successful at managing conflict and resolving political
grievances particularly those that relate to national minorities. Accordingly the design of the political
institutions and the electoral system, in particular, performs an important role in managing conflict and
providing a peaceful outlet directing the interests that may otherwise fuel conflict into effective
participation in public life. This is particularly so in societies in which there are competing ethnic
groups. If an electoral system does not address the real needs of a society and the social formations
within it, it will not only lead to political and administrative difficulties but may, itself, be the cause of
conflict. It follows therefore that an important practical application of the Lund Recommendations is
to firstly review the existing electoral system and to improve the design, if necessary, to achieve that
objective.
Electoral systems can be specifically constructed to address the particular needs in a society. This is
because they prescribe how votes are translated into seats. The choice of system can lead to different
outcomes on the same number of votes. For example an electoral system based on constituencies will
often lead to a different result from a system of strict proportional representation.23 This may, in
23
For example in the last election in 1997 in the United Kingdom, forty three percent of the vote secured sixty three percent of the seats (418 in
total) for the Labour Party. A strictly proportional representation system would have given them only 283 seats. A particularly stark example