-3This work is particularly challenging in the context of the OSCE region, where the process of
nation-building is still dynamic in a number of States. Efforts to consolidate national
identities that focus on one community’s ethnic identity while ignoring others can give rise to
feelings of resentment rather than unity. Such efforts may be guided by short-term political
considerations, a misperception that diversity is a weakness rather than a strength, or desires
to redress distant or more recent historical injustices. The reasons States fail to promote an
inclusive civic identity can even be understandable, but the consequences can be catastrophic.
That is why it is critical for authorities to use wisely the power that has been vested in them.
Sovereign States have rights but they also have responsibilities and legal obligations,
including the responsibility to protect human rights including minority rights, to practice
democratic governance and not to discriminate. Promoting the integration of society is
another important State responsibility, as stated in the Ljubljana Guidelines on Integration of
Diverse Societies. This means the adoption and implementation of policies aimed at
promoting integration in areas such as language, education, participation, media and access to
justice. The Ljubljana Guidelines and my Institution’s other thematic recommendations
provide guidance to States on the development of such policies.
In the work of my Institution we have also seen how States can use their power beyond its
jurisdiction, using so-called “kin” minorities in other States as an excuse for excessive
intervention and even the provocation of violence. As noted in the Bolzano/Bozen
Recommendations on National Minorities in Inter-state Relations, concerns for minorities in
other States can be legitimate but should be addressed in the frameworks and mechanisms
provided by international law. Questions of motives and credibility arise when States
demonstrate greater interest in minorities abroad than at home. And the international
community has the responsibility to use the power at its disposal to stop abuses and atrocities
before they occur.
The great Desmond Tutu once said that he told the apartheid government: “You may have the
guns, you may have all this power, but you have already lost. Come: join the winning side.”
The winning side is where all members of society have a voice, where all enjoy equal access
to opportunities and where lines are not drawn on the basis of racial, ethnic or other identities.
I hope that in the course of this Forum, we will learn together about how we can all be on the
winning side.