E/CN.4/2004/76/Add.3
page 15
58.
The Special Rapporteur takes a positive view of the fact that the Act explicitly provides
certain guarantees for foreign nationals who are placed in custody: judicial review of the
decision, a time limit on administrative detention, administrative remedies, registration of those
held in custody, information from the royal prosecutor, who must visit the holding area and
inspect the physical conditions, the provision of medical aid, interpretation and counsel, and
facilities for informing the consulate authorities and contacting a person of choice.
59.
The Special Rapporteur is concerned that the time limit (48 hours) for appealing against
an expulsion order may not be sufficient to obtain the necessary facilities for preparing the
appeal and contacting a counsel of choice. Account must be taken of the fact that the person is
in a foreign country and does not know the language, the law or the procedures to be followed.
60.
The Special Rapporteur was told that the Act explicitly establishes categories of
individuals liable to expulsion - pregnant women, minors and any other foreign national whose
life or liberty would be threatened or who would run the risk of inhuman, cruel or degrading
treatment - who may not be expelled. In such cases, the Act establishes compulsory residence
measures and an obligation to report regularly to the police station or gendarmerie. In that
regard, the Special Rapporteur wishes to highlight the importance of ensuring a degree of
protection by establishing special measures for minors and pregnant women, whose status
prevents them from being expelled even if they are technically liable to expulsion. The measures
applicable in these cases are not explicitly set forth in the Act: it does not state clearly whether
they are to be placed in custody or confined to their residence or whether any measures of
protection have been put in place for them.
61.
The Special Rapporteur notes that infringements of the immigration regulations are liable
to criminal and administrative action, with a view to discouraging illegal migration. The
detention of migrants in an irregular situation should under no circumstances be punitive in
nature. In this regard, the Special Rapporteur wishes to emphasize that account must always be
taken, in applying criminal law, of migrants’ individual history. Additional guarantees should be
provided to help irregular migrants who, even when guilty of infringements of immigration law,
are in fact eligible to apply for asylum. From information received and her own observations,
the Special Rapporteur notes that neither the authorities responsible for law and order and for
control of air, sea and land borders, nor the judicial authorities, have clear information regarding
refugee status. There are reportedly 2,245 refugees on Moroccan territory and only 720 of them
receive financial support from the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees
(UNHCR). The UNHCR Office in Casablanca does not have sufficient financial resources to
help this vulnerable group and is not sufficiently visible or well enough known among the
migrant community.
62.
The Special Rapporteur warmly welcomes the provisions of the Act aimed at punishing
smugglers and traffickers of human beings and combating corruption among officials who
facilitate illegal migration. She notes, however, that no measures of protection have been put in
place for the victims of such trafficking.