A/HRC/37/55
externalize good feelings onto the symbols of their own groups and bad feelings onto the
symbols of the groups that are enemies.34 States have an important responsibility to ensure
that educational systems do not reinforce antagonisms that question the universality of
human dignity but instead actively challenge these assumptions and nurture a culture of
human rights, tolerance and respect for diversity.
49.
Reassessing the humanity of one’s enemy involves acknowledging the complexities
of one’s own group as well. In contexts of slavery and long-standing oppression, discourses
about identity generally become singular and thin, crafted in the service of the collective
narratives through which claims are justified, the conflict is waged and repression is
exercised. It is often the case that both victims and perpetrators, oppressed and oppressors,
may have lost a sense of their full humanity. Artistic and cultural initiatives can allow
people to transcend particular identities and reinforce identities that unite rather than divide.
50.
In Burundi, drumming groups of boys in which all ethnic groups were represented
existed before the ethnic violence of the 1990s erupted. The participants had built groups
around the shared practice where they experienced values of inter-ethnic trust and
solidarity, and chose to emphasize their identity as drummers over their ethnic origin.
Between March 1994 and March 1998, the drummers continued playing and performing in
different neighbourhoods, supported each other and saved each other’s lives repeatedly. 35
The peacebuilding NGO Search for Common Ground worked along the same lines through
the end of the 1990s to counteract dehumanizing stereotypes that scarred the relationships
between Hutu, Tutsi and Twa people. 36 Through music, dance, drumming and the
production of radio programmes, they provided spaces where it was possible to recognize
the humanity of the other and contributed to a new understanding of the conflict in terms of
a political struggle for power rather than in ethnic terms.
2.
Listening to and telling stories and empathizing with the suffering of the other
51.
The previous holder of the mandate in the field of cultural rights has noted the role
historical narratives play in shaping collective identities. She also noted that self-expression
through artistic creativity was indispensable to making victims visible. 37 The capacity to
shape experience into narrative is one important way that victims can determine the
meaning surrounding hurtful and traumatic events such as human rights violations, and
thereby regain a measure of empowerment. Violence, however, can strip people of their
capacities to compose and tell their stories, as well as their capacities to listen and be
receptive to the stories of others.
52.
Artists and cultural workers can serve as listeners, help people once deemed
adversaries compose their stories in ways that “others” can hear and raise questions about
the possibility of forgiveness, even of oneself. Loosening the grip of a particular monolithic
narrative (of victimization, for instance) opens possibilities for more nuanced stories and
more complex understandings of history.
53.
The potential of story-sharing to restore relationships across economic and racial
divides has been made apparent in a recent project in the Western Cape, South Africa. In
order to involve the people living on his newly inherited land in planning the reorganization
of his wine farm, Mark Solms, a white South African, first had to find a way to establish a
respectful dialogue. With the help of historians and archaeologists, the workers and Solms
literally and figuratively excavated the farm’s land and its history of past slavery and
apartheid that linked their families together, and constructed a heritage/oral history project
through which everyone shared and listened to each other’s stories and memories. This
34
35
36
37
V. Volkan, “An overview of psychological concepts pertinent to interethnic and/or international
relationships”, in The Psychodynamics of International Relationships, vol. I, Concepts and Theories,
V. Volkan, D.A. Julius and J.V. Montville, eds. (Lexington Books, 1990).
L. Slachmuijlder, “The rhythm of reconciliation: a reflection on drumming as a contribution to
reconciliation processes in Rwanda, Burundi, and South Africa”, Recasting Reconciliation through
Culture and the Arts, Brandeis University Programme in Peacebuilding and the Arts, 2004.
See www.sfcg.org.
See A/HRC/28/36, paras. 9−10.
11