E/CN.4/1999/58/Add.1
page 18
non-believers and indifferent to religious matters or who consider that the
communities' demands are for privileges rather than for rights. Still
according to Laycock, in the United States “the conflict is between the
religiously intense and the religiously unintense”. We may note, moreover,
that for most minorities, to remedy this situation, and in particular to
resolve specific problems such as refusals relating to places of worship,
would take a great deal of time and money.
50.
Concerning Scientology, its representatives declared that their
organization had been recognized as a religion in the United States since 1993
and that it had 42 churches with 3 million members. As regards the
information collected by the Special Rapporteur during his visit on the
existence of forced labour camps - the “Rehabilitation programme” - and
Scientology's harassment of its former members and its critics, even including
killings, the representatives of the organization firmly rejected those
accusations and sent the Special Rapporteur a detailed dossier in which they
explained that: (a) the Rehabilitation Programme was a voluntary religious
retreat emphasizing intensive contemplation and concentrated religious
studies, balanced by a certain form of physical labour, and that it was not
“brainwashing”; (b) Scientology's ethical code prohibited illegal activities,
and hence the organization's detractors were not the object of harassment, but
of legal proceedings; (c) the deaths of certain Scientologists in Florida were
accidental.
51.
As far as atheism is concerned, it is a movement which, for the time
being, is developing and organizing among the population on a modest scale,
generally because of its non-acceptance by the society, in which religion
remains a very strong point of reference in social, cultural and identity
terms. However, some organizations, such as the Free Thought Society of
Greater Philadelphia and the Anti-discrimination Support Network play an
active role aimed in particular at securing genuine recognition for atheism
and respect for the rights such recognition would entail. Apart from
contesting State-supported religious symbols, which to a degree are imposed on
everyone, such as the mottos “In God We Trust” on United States currency and
“One Nation Under God” in the Declaration of Allegiance to the national flag,
and various oaths which include a reference to God, these organizations
complain about discriminatory situations and bring court proceedings with
regard to them, in particular the obligation to sign an oath to God in order
to join the Boy Scouts of America.
C.
Situation of Native Americans
52.
The situation of the Native Americans was discussed in depth with
officials, including the Assistant Secretary of the Interior for Indian
Affairs, representatives of the Native Americans and non-governmental
organizations and various personalities.
53.
The Native Americans are without any doubt the community facing the most
problematical situation, one inherited from a past of denial of their
religious identity, in particular through a policy of assimilation, which most
Native Americans insist on calling genocide (physical liquidation, religious
conversion, attempts to destroy their traditional way of life, laying waste of
land, etc.).