CCPR/C/70/D/547/1993
Page 3
The Treaty of Waitangi is not enforceable in New Zealand law except insofar as it is given force
of law in whole or in part by Parliament in legislation. However, it imposes obligations on the
Crown and claims under the Treaty can be investigated by the Waitangi Tribunal. 3
5.2 No attempt was made to determine the extent of the fisheries until the introduction of the
Quota Management System in the 1980s. That system, which constitutes the primary mechanism
for the conservation of New Zealand's fisheries resources and for the regulation of commercial
fishing in New Zealand, allocates permanent, transferable, property rights in quota for each
commercial species within the system.
5.3
The New Zealand fishing industry had seen a drama tic growth in the early 1960s with the
expansion of an exclusive fisheries zone of nine, and later twelve miles. At that time, all New
Zealanders, including Maori, could apply for and be granted a commercial fishing permit; the
majority of commercial fishers were not Maori, and of those who were, the majority were parttime fishers. By the early 1980s, inshore fisheries were over-exploited and the Government
placed a moratorium on the issue of new permits and removed part-time fishers from the
industry. This measure had the unintended effect of removing many of the Maori fishers from
the commercial industry. Since the efforts to manage the commercial fishery fell short of what
was needed, in 1986 the Government amended the existing Fisheries Act and introduced a quota
management system for the commercial use and exploitation of the country's fisheries. Section
88 (2) of the Fisheries Act provides "that nothing in this Act shall affect any Maori fishing
rights". In 1987, the Maori tribes filed an application with the High Court of New Zealand,
claiming that the implementation of the quota system would affect their tribal Treaty rights
contrary to section 88(2) of the Fisheries Act, and obtained interim injunctions against the
Government.
5.4
In 1988, the Government started negotiations with Maori, who were represented by four
representatives. The Maori representatives were given a mandate to negotiate to obtain 50% of
all New Zealand commercial fisheries. In 1989, after negotiation and as an interim measure,
Maori agreed to the introduction of the Maori Fisheries Act 1989, which provided for the
immediate transfer of 10% of all quota to a Maori Fisheries Commission which would
administer the resource on behalf of the tribes. This allowed the introduction of the quota system
to go ahead as scheduled. Under the Act, Maori can also apply to manage the fishery in areas
which had customarily been of special significance to a tribe or sub-tribe, either as a source of
food or for spiritual reasons.
5.5
Although the Maori Fisheries Act 1989 was understood as an interim measure only, there
were limited opportunities to purchase any more significant quantities of quota on the market. In
February 1992, Maori became aware that Sealords, the largest fishing company in Australia and
New Zealand was likely to be publicly floated at some time during that year. The Maori
Fisheries Negotiators and the Maori Fisheries Commission approached the Government with a
3
The Waitangi Tribunal is a specialized statutory body established by the Treaty of Waitangi Act 1975 having
the status of a commission of enquiry and empowered inter alia to inquire into certain claims in relation to the
principles of the Treaty of Waitangi.