A/HRC/25/58/Add.2
41.
In addition to religious instruction in the strict sense of the word (namely, education
given with the intention of familiarizing students with their own faith), the school can and
should also provide information about religions, philosophies and beliefs in the context of
history, geography, literature or other disciplines, in order to overcome misunderstandings
and negative stereotypes. Education should include basic information about religions that
do not traditionally exist in the country. Equally important is information about intrareligious diversity, including different Christian denominations and different branches of
Islam. The Special Rapporteur was informed in this context that many negative stereotypes
against Shias exist in Jordan. Resentment and prejudices seem to have increased in recent
years. On the one hand, this may reflect the current political conflicts within the Arab
region; on the other, prejudices may also be based on gross misunderstandings of the
religious teachings of Shia Islam. School education can and should play a role in
overcoming misunderstandings by providing appropriate information.
42.
Representatives of Christian communities requested that history books used in
schools be more appropriately include the Christian heritage in Jordan and other Arab
countries which, they stated, is largely ignored in text books.3 Moreover, they asserted that,
if Christianity is addressed in teaching materials, this is typically done from an Islamic
point of view, which does not do justice to the self-understanding of Christians. According
to information provided to the Special Rapporteur, it seems that, while history books used
in school generally inform students about non-Islamic religions, including in particular
Christianity, the specific regional heritage of Christianity in Jordan or in the broader Arab
world is not appropriately covered.
43.
In textbooks and curricula used for Muslim instruction, Christianity is generally
presented through the lens of Islamic teachings. Representatives of various Christian
denominations with whom the Special Rapporteur discussed this issue mentioned the socalled “Barnabas gospel” as a particularly disturbing misrepresentation of Christianity in
curricula and textbooks used in school.4 The so-called “Barnabas gospel”, thought by many
researchers to have originated in sixteenth-century Spain, naturally does not belong to
traditional Islamic teaching based on the Koran or the Hadith. It nonetheless features in
curricula and textbooks used for Muslim instruction in public schools.
44.
The Special Rapporteur underlines the conceptual difference between, on the one
hand, religious instruction that has the intention of familiarizing students with their own
religious tradition, and “neutral” information on religious issues provided in history,
geography or literature classes, on the other. It is important to maintain this distinction not
only conceptually but also in practice.5 This important differentiation has implications also
for the contents of curricula and textbooks. In any case, textbooks used in schools should
aim to do justice to the self-understanding of religious communities and their members in
order to contribute to the elimination of misperceptions that often negatively affect relations
between people of different persuasions.
3
4
5
It should be noted that a Roman Catholic priest also complained about the general ignorance of the
realities of Arab Christendom in Europe.
This was confirmed by a study conducted by Professor Wolfram Reiss on the basis of the Jordanian
curricula. See Klaus Hock, Johannes Lähnemann and Wolfram Reiss, Die Darstellung des
Christentums in Schulbüchern islamisch geprägter Länder, Teil 3: Libanon und Jordanien (Berlin:
EB-Verlag, 2012), p. 479.
A/HRC/16/53, para. 31.
13