A/77/290
rights. 113 This grass-roots campaign ultimately succeeded, with the property
developer withdrawing from the site in August 2021 – a rare victory for the protection
of minority cultures in the face of large-scale economic development.
93. Development for the purposes of urban regeneration is not sustainable or rightsrespecting when it gentrifies lower-income and/ or minority neighbourhoods. This is
the case even for seemingly positive environmental improvements or amenities
(e.g. parks, trees and trails) that raise property values – a phenomenon one could
described as “green” or “environmental” gentrification. 114 As city planners and
developers increasingly seek to improve urban green spaces to mitigate the effects of
climate change, precautionary measures must be taken to protect against
gentrification and its accompanying cultural impoverishment.
VII. Conclusions and recommendations
94. Cultural rights are at the core of sustainable development processes and
should be recognized in that capacity. They are about the “how”, the manner in
which we live our lives, how we see our world and how we transmit our values.
Accordingly, cultural diversity is crucial for the human ecosystem and for the
sustainability and resilience of the wider ecosystems, together with biodiversity,
to which it is interlinked. Cultural diversity opens avenues towards
implementation that recognizes the value of both traditional and modern
knowledge and encourages their synergies.
95. Recalling that the Sustainable Development Goals are a voluntary process
enshrined in human rights that remain obligations under international law, the
Special Rapporteur underlines that no violation of human rights, including
cultural rights, may be justified in the name of development or sustainable
development.
96. There is a need to adopt a human-rights-based approach that includes
cultural rights throughout the implementation and monitoring of Goals. The
indivisibility, universality and interdependence of all human rights ensure
coherence and provide clear red lines to guarantee sustainability and prevent
harm; the realization of one human right cannot be isolated from its impacts on
other rights, either in planning, implementation or impact assessment and
evaluation.
97. In many cases, “development” policies and strategies reflecting dominant
cultural viewpoints or those of the most powerful sectors of society, with historic
ties to colonialism and domination, are designed and implemented to the
detriment of the most vulnerable in a manner that impedes the future sustainable
development and survival of these persons and communities and probably, in the
longer term, of humanity. The need to accept and consider frameworks that sit
outside mainstream approaches has become urgent. Cultural diversity is as key
to our future as biodiversity is; they are interrelated.
98. People and peoples must be the primary beneficiaries of sustainable
development processes. The Special Rapporteur recommends, in particular, that
States, international organizations and other stakeholders ensure that
sustainable development processes:
(a) Are culturally sensitive and appropriate, contextualised to specific
cultural environments and seek to fully align themselves with the aspirations,
__________________
113
114
22-12659
See joint allegation letters JAL GBR 3/2017 and GBR 1/2019. See also https://savelatinvillage.org.
uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Haringey-Council-15-Mar-2019.pdf.
Colin Luoma in expert consultation.
23/24