E/2009/43
E/C.19/2009/14
11. The voting of the General Assembly, which proves that a great majority of the
international community stands behind the Declaration, is a significant factor when
determining the legal strength of the Declaration. Article 38 of the Statute of the
International Court of Justice, stating the sources of international law that the Court
shall apply, includes among them “the general principles of law recognized by
civilized nations”. The Declaration is formulated on “principles of law”, having
“rights” as the main concept, and the worldwide adherence to the Declaration, with
the small and shrinking group of negative States, may soon be considered as a
fulfilment of the criterion of the “civilized nations”.
12. The combined effect of these elements gives the Declaration a growing legal
status. It might be argued that the Declaration in its entirety already has acquired the
status of being part of binding international law. In any way, this is the case already
for a number of the articles.
13. The understanding of the Declaration here described shall form the basis on
which the Forum is going to undertake its activities. The Forum has already
included an item on the Declaration on its agenda.
The effect of article 42
14. This new function assigned to the Forum pursuant to article 42 is far-reaching.
The formulas of the provision are of a twofold nature.
15. In the first place, the Forum shall promote not only respect for but also “full
application” of the Declaration. This implies that the Forum shall work to promote
the incorporation of the Declaration into national legislation as well as its
application in the national courts and administrative decisions of the various
countries.
16. Second, the Forum shall follow up “the effectiveness” of the Declaration, that
is, to see whether the realities (“law in action”) are in conformity with the written
law and decisions (“law in books”), and if not, take necessary actions to close the
implementation gap.
17. This new and extensive responsibility does not, in the wording of the article,
correspond with any authority to accomplish what is required in this regard. The
authority of the Forum will accordingly have to be decided by way of a reading of
article 42 on the basis of the Declaration as a whole. In this process of interpretation
one has to rely on some principles or guidelines that are within the spirit of the
Declaration.
18. Some accepted guidelines for interpretation will in this case be the workings of
the Forum so far, the purpose of article 42 and the normal way of protecting human
rights within the United Nations system.
19. The present working arrangement of the Forum has to be a starting point for
the reading of the new article. The purpose of article 42 is to contribute to the
effectiveness of the Declaration, and the reading of the Article should therefore give
preference to working methods for the Forum that are oriented towards substantial
results for the indigenous peoples as rights holders. Looking to the normal way of
protecting human rights within the United Nations system will also find support in
the wording of the article, where the Forum is placed on a par with other bodies of
the United Nations.
09-36351
21