A/HRC/13/40/Add.1
Y.
1.
(a)
Viet Nam
Communication sent on 25 November 2009 jointly with the Special Rapporteur on
adequate housing as a component of the right to an adequate standard of living and
on the right to non-discrimination in this context, and the Special Rapporteur on the
promotion and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression
Allegations transmitted to the Government
259. The Special Rapporteurs brought to the attention of the Government information
they had received regarding the recent eviction of monks and nuns from Bat Nha
monastery and their future eviction from Phuoc Hue temple, due to take place on 30
November 2009.
260. On 27 September 2009, about 150 people armed with sticks and hammers attacked
the Bat Nha monastery. Plain-clothes police officers were reportedly amongst the mob and
police officers in uniform blocked the roads leading to the monastery. The mob violently
proceeded to the eviction of 379 monks and nuns from the monastery. Some monks and
nuns were beaten up and four of them were sexually assaulted. According to the reports, the
monks did not attempt to defend themselves, but they sat down and started to chant in order
to respond in a non-violent manner to the attacks. Two senior brothers, Mr. Phap Hoi and
Mr. Phap Sy, were beaten and would be still held under house arrest without proper charges
in Hanoi and Nha Trang.
261. After being evicted, the monks and nuns were offered refuge by Mr. Thai Thuan, the
abbot of Phuoc Hue temple in Bao Loc. On 28 September 2009, the police threatened the
abbot, claiming he had no right to offer refuge to the Bat Nha monks and nuns. The police
then surrounded the temple and they started an intimidation campaign. Flyers were
distributed in Bao Loc in order to damage the reputation of the abbot and he was denounced
through loudspeakers in schools and in the streets. Police officers threatened to undertake
attacks on Phuoc Hue temple similar to the ones undertaken against the Bat Nha monastery
on 27 September 2009. The intimidation campaign culminated with the demand that the
abbot surrender fifteen monks and nuns. Under this extreme pressure, the abbot acceded to
the demand and surrendered fifteen monks and nuns, who were taken into police custody
and were driven more than 200 km away from Ho Chi Minh city.
262. The other Bat Nha monks and nuns who currently remain in Phuoc Hue temple were
still reportedly undergoing pressure and threats from the authorities to leave the temple.
They were living under strict control of the police. The police harassed and obstructed
people who were bringing food and clothing to the temple. Anyone who stopped in the
vicinity of the temple was being stopped and questioned.
263. Concerns were expressed that the crackdown on the Bat Nha Buddhist community
was due to the teachings of Mr. Thich Nhat Hanh, leader of the Bat Nha Buddhist
community. Mr. Thich Nhat Hanh would have made public recommendations in 2007 in
order to improve the situation of religious freedom in the Socialist Republic of Vietnam,
including a request to disband the country’s religious police.
264. The Special Rapporteurs urged the Government to take all necessary measures to
guarantee that the rights and freedoms of the members of the Bat Nha Buddhist community
are respected and that accountability of any person guilty of the alleged violations is
ensured. The Special Rapporteurs also requested that the Government adopts effective
measures to prevent the recurrence of these acts.
60