E/CN.4/1992/52
page 27
It is rather unfortunate that some immigration authorities and human
rights activists have accepted without question hideous allegations of
persecution by economic refugees fleeing from their responsibilities in
developing countries to greener pastures in developed industrialized countries.
It may be pointed out that not until developing countries have attained
some higher level of development and industrialized countries have liberalized
their immigration restrictions to nationals from developing countries, such
lies and allegations would continue to be made."
42. In a communication sent on 25 April 1991 addressed to the Government of
Greece, the following information was transmitted by the Special Rapporteur:
"According to the information received, a decree concerning a new
procedure for the selection of Muftis has been issued on 24 December 1990. It
has been alleged that the decree introduces interference in the determination
of religious representatives by the Muslim community. It has been asserted in
particular that it is the Prefect who establishes the commission examining the
candidates and has the right to express his own opinion concerning their
suitability. It has been further reported that the Minister of National
Education and Religious Affairs has the final choice with regard to the
candidate, which would make it an appointment rather than an election by the
religious community itself. It has also been reported that the Mufti, who
would be required to take a public service oath in the presence of the
Prefect, could be dismissed by the Prefect who is allegedly also empowered to
appoint a replacement."
43. On 31 May 1991, the Permanent Mission of Greece to the United Nations
Office at Geneva addressed a reply to the Special Rapporteur regarding the
above-mentioned allegations, which stated the following:
"The Legislative Act regarding Muslim Religious Ministers in Thrace
provides as follows:
A.
An enlarged committee is convened by the official, superior to the
Prefect, namely the competent Regional Secretary-General. This committee
chaired by the Prefect consists of Greek Muslim clergy and prominent Greek
Muslim citizens. They propose to the Minister of Education and Religious
Affairs a list of qualified persons (holders of a university degree of high
Islamic School, national or foreign, or holders of itzazetname diploma, or
persons having served as imam for at least ten years and who distinguished
themselves for their morality and theological proficiency). From among them,
the Minister chooses on the basis of personal qualification of each
candidate. The Mufti is finally appointed by presidential decree issued upon
proposal of the Minister of Education.
In this connection it should be recalled that the appointment by the
State of a head of clergy is common practice in countries where Islam
constitutes the predominant religion (e.g. Egypt, Tunisia, Morocco, Jordan,
Turkey, etc.).