A/71/254
C.
The need for disaggregated data
22. Although some studies on specific displacement situations affecting minorities
do exist, the Special Rapporteur has observed that there is a lack of accurate, global,
disaggregated data that would allow for a clearer global picture of how minorities
are affected by humanitarian crises, whether driven by conflict or owing to
disasters. While some ad hoc case studies are available on specific situations, much
work remains to be done to better document this phenomenon globally through the
collection of comprehensive disaggregated data.
23. The Special Rapporteur is aware that there are a number of reasons underlying
the lack of readily available data in this field. First, there is the likely reluctance of
minorities displaced or affected by crises to identify themselves as ethnic, national,
religious or linguistic minorities for fear of further discrimination or violence.
Second, States may be unwilling to collect such data, insofar as they do not
recognize the affected minority group members as citizens, do not recognize their
minority status, do not recognize they have been displaced or do not want to draw
attention to specific difficulties faced by members of their societies. Finally, in
displacement contexts, humanitarian agencies tend to disaggregate data mainly by
sex and age, and rarely address other categories, including minority status or special
needs. The lack of accurate data and needs assessment of specific groups such as
minorities has therefore had an impact on the ability to develop humanitarian
programmes that target and address comprehensively discrimination facing
minorities in the context of crises.
24. Greater research and data is therefore required to reveal the full impact of
humanitarian crises and disasters on minority communities. In particular, it is
necessary to disaggregate data not only by sex and age but also by diversity
categories, such as ethnicity and religion that should be determined by contextual
realities. Such information, fully adhering to international standards of data
protection and use, should be voluntary, and would help to pre dict and prevent
disproportionate impacts of crises conflicts and disasters against certain
communities and contribute to the development of much -needed risk assessment
and early warning mechanisms.
D.
Defining humanitarian crises
25. A humanitarian crisis can be defined as the experience of a country, region or
society of a total or considerable breakdown of authority resulting from internal or
external conflict and which requires an international response that goes beyond the
mandate or capacity of any single agency and/or the ongoing United Nations
country programme.
26. At the national level, this may involve internal armed conflict or hostilities
within a State. At the international level, this may involve international armed
conflict between two or more armed forces of different countries. Such outbreaks of
conflict may cause large-scale mass movements of people, as they flee violence and
chaos. This can lead to internal displacement, as well as international migration
flows, as affected individuals and communities flee their homes within their own
country as internally displaced persons, or migrate abroad, including through
16-13193
9/25