A/75/329
stated in the guidelines that disease names should not include geographic locations
nor cultural, population, industry or occupational references.
78. Systemic racism and inequality permeate public health responses to the
pandemic. Discrimination in access to medical services is pervasive. Disparities in
access to testing, to emergency medical services and to isolation centres, and in the
ability to practise appropriate social distancing, are reported in nearly every
submission that the Special Rapporteur has received. Pre-existing inequalities result
in discrimination in access to health care and differential susceptibility to COVID-19
transmission. According to the Equal Rights Trust, a June 2020 review by Public
Health England (an executive agency of the Department of Health and Social Care in
the United Kingdom) found a likely correlation between the risk of transmission of
the virus responsible for COVID-19 for black, Asian and minority ethnic communities
in England, and prevailing health disparities, such as overcrowded housing, reliance
on public transport, and living in densely populated areas. Similarly, the death rate
for these communities is associated with a high underlying risk of co-morbidities, for
example cardiovascular disease, diabetes and obesity. 46 The review further noted that
“the measures to control the spread of COVID-19 across the country may have led to
further economic or housing instability”. 47
79. Furthermore, the Equal Rights Trust reported that a June 2020 study by the APM
Research Lab in the United States had found that a quarter of COVID-19 deaths in
the United States had been of black people (almost 22,000), although they constituted
only about 13 per cent of the population. A Brazilian study of health service data o n
30,000 COVID-19 patients who had either recovered or died as at 18 May 2020 found
that proportionately more black and mixed-race Brazilians (55 per cent) had died than
whites (38 per cent), exposing similar underlying inequalities. 48 The Equal Rights
Trust also reported on another study that found that the COVID-19-related death rate
for indigenous peoples in Brazil was over 9 per cent, nearly double the 5.2 per cent
rate among the general Brazilian population. 49
80. As compared with Jewish Israelis, Adalah reported major gaps in access to
emergency medical services, COVID-19 testing, and isolation facilities for
Palestinian citizens of Israel, including Palestinian Bedouin in the Negev, as well as
Palestinian residents of Occupied East Jerusalem. Adalah stated that litigation and
substantial pressure by civil society and political actors had prompted the
Government to provide a minimum of health-related services. However, these gaps
were still significant during the first wave of the pandemic, and Adalah n oted an
apparent lack of preparedness for these groups in the second wave. 50 While the Israeli
Ministry of Health publishes a daily update on COVID-19, Adalah reports that it does
not include accurate data on the considerable population of Palestinian citi zens who
live in mixed Jewish-Arab cities (e.g. Acre, Haifa and Ramla). They often live in
segregated, overcrowded and poorer neighbourhoods that lack adequate health and
social services, which puts them at higher risk for COVID-19. Adalah noted that “the
lack of specific information on these towns was especially damaging during that
crucial period for mapping the pandemic’s spread in order to formulate specific
interventions in communities under heightened risk”. 51
__________________
46
47
48
49
50
51
18/23
Equal Rights Trust submission, para. 15.
Ibid., para. 15.
Ibid., para. 16.
Ibid., para. 17.
Submission from Adalah, p. 3.
Ibid., pp. 10–11.
20-11206