A/75/590
(b) Adopt mandatory policies and practices for systemic analysis of
potential harmful and discriminatory impacts of digital border technologies
prior to the adoption of these technologies, and prohibit adoption of technologies
that cannot be shown to meet equality and non-discrimination requirements.
Provide clearer, more concrete human rights-based guidelines on the criteria for
the designation of “zero option” digital technologies, and ensure the
implementation of these guidelines;
(c) Adopt mandatory ongoing human rights assessment protocols for
digital border technologies once deployed;
(d) Create mechanisms for independent human rights oversight of use by
IOM of digital border technologies and implement reforms to ensure greater
transparency in how decisions are made to adopt these technologies;
(e) Provide migrants, refugees, stateless persons and related groups with
mechanisms for holding IOM directly accountable for violations of their human
rights resulting from the use of digital border technologies.
61. Relative to IOM, UNHCR has taken greater steps to engage with equality
and non-discrimination norms in its guidance frameworks relating to digital
border technologies, but it too has significant additional work to do to ensure
that those norms are realized in its practice. In this regard, the Special
Rapporteur makes the recommendations set out below.
62.
UNHCR should:
(a) Adopt mandatory policies and practices for systemic analysis of
potential harmful and discriminatory impacts of digital border technologies
prior to the adoption of these technologies, and prohibit adoption of technologies
that cannot be shown to meet equality and non-discrimination requirements.
Provide clearer, more concrete human rights-based guidelines on the criteria for
the designation of “zero option” digital technologies, and ensure the
implementation of these guidelines;
(b) Adopt mandatory ongoing human rights assessment protocols for
digital border technologies once deployed;
(c) Create mechanisms for independent human rights oversight of the use
by UNHCR of digital border technologies and implement reforms to ensure
greater transparency in how decisions are made to adopt these technologies;
(d) Provide migrants, refugees, stateless persons and related groups with
mechanisms for holding UNHCR directly accountable for violations of their
human rights resulting from the use of digital border technologies.
63. All United Nations humanitarian and related bodies should implement the
recommendations above addressed to IOM and UNHCR.
20-14872
25/25