A/HRC/20/33/Add.1
interlocutors expressed concern about the way the process for the adoption of the new
Constitution had been carried out, including the limited time frame established for its
adoption, the lack of transparency and adequate consultation of the general public, and the
limited opportunities for an adequate public debate.
12.
The new Constitution2 contains provisions of particular relevance to the mandate of
the Special Rapporteur, including article XV, which prescribes that “(1) Every person shall
be equal before the law. Every human being shall have legal capacity. (2) Hungary shall
ensure fundamental rights to every person without any discrimination on the grounds of
race, colour, sex, disability, language, religion, political or other views, national or social
origin, financial, birth or other circumstances whatsoever. […] (4) Hungary shall adopt
special measures to promote the implementation of legal equality”.
13.
The other relevant provisions concern the Hungarian ethnic and national minorities
referred to as “Nationalities”. Article XXIX affirms that “(1) Nationalities living in
Hungary shall be constituent parts of the State. Every Hungarian citizen belonging to any
nationality shall have the right to freely express and preserve his or her identity.
Nationalities living in Hungary shall have the right to use their native language and to the
individual and collective use of names in their own languages, to promote their own
cultures, and to be educated in their native languages. (2) Nationalities living in Hungary
shall have the right to establish local and national self-governments. (3) The detailed rules
for the rights of nationalities living in Hungary and the rules for the elections of their local
and national self-governments shall be defined by a cardinal Act”. The Special Rapporteur
notes with concern that the new Constitution no longer stipulates explicitly whether the
rights recognized as belonging to minorities will be guaranteed and supported by the State.
Furthermore, the Constitution no longer includes provisions regarding the collective
participation of minorities in public affairs and their representation. Article 2 (2) of the
Constitution under the Chapter entitled “State” only prescribes that “Nationalities living in
Hungary shall contribute to Parliament’s work as defined by a cardinal Act”. Finally, while
the new Constitution declares the right for minorities to use their native languages, article H
only provides for the protection of the Hungarian language without referring to other
languages.3
14.
With regard to non-citizens, article XIV (3) states that “Hungary shall grant asylum
to all non-Hungarian citizens as requested if they are being persecuted or have a wellfounded fear of persecution in their native countries or in the countries of their usual
residence due to their racial or national identities, affiliation to a particular social group, or
to their religious or political persuasions, unless they receive protection from their countries
of origin or any other country”. The Special Rapporteur welcomes such provisions.
However he is concerned that some human rights are granted to Hungarian citizens, but not
to non-citizens including for instance the right to education (article XI (1)) and the
enjoyment of social security (article XIX (1)).
2
3
6
Available from http://www.kormany.hu/download/2/ab/30000/Alap_angol.pdf
Article H “(1) In Hungary the official language shall be Hungarian. (2) Hungary shall protect the
Hungarian language. (3) Hungary shall protect Hungarian Sign Language as a part of Hungarian
culture”.