98
PROMOTING AND PROTECTING MINORITY RIGHTS
admissible. An author, his or her legal representative and the State are entitled to be represented
at the hearing.
Since 1994, the Commission has undertaken a number of on-site investigations of communications,
although these may occur only with the consent of the State concerned. Reports from such
missions are adopted as part of the proceedings and may also be published by the Commission
separately, prior to a final decision on the communication. The Commission also may take into
account information provided by United Nations special procedures (see chap. IV) in determining
whether allegations contained in individual complaints are well founded.
After hearing the parties and completing any investigation, the Commission deliberates, reaches
its decision and adopts its report in the case.121 All of these actions are taken in camera. However,
NGOs recognized as observers “may be invited specially to be present at closed sessions
dealing with issues of particular interest to them”.122 The Commission’s conclusions are not
legally binding on States, but the Commission does reach direct conclusions that a State has (or
has not) violated specific articles of the Charter. If the Commission concludes that Charter rights
have been violated, it adopts recommendations and indicates appropriate remedial measures
for the harm suffered by the victim(s). The recommendations of the Commission are sent to the
parties and annexed to the Commission’s annual report, publication of which is approved every
year by the Assembly of the African Union.
At any time, a case may be closed if the parties reach a settlement. Although the Commission is
not specifically directed under the Charter to seek such a “friendly settlement”, the Commission
has made it clear that this is its preferred course. “The main goal of the communications procedure
before the Commission is to initiate a positive dialogue, resulting in an amicable resolution
between the complainant and the State concerned, which remedies the prejudice complained of.
A pre-requisite for amicably remedying violations of the Charter is the good faith of the parties
concerned, including their willingness to participate in a dialogue.”123
Fact-finding missions
The African Commission also undertakes fact-finding missions to investigate allegation of serious
and massive human rights violations within a member State, as provided for in article 58 of the
Charter (which refers to these as “special cases”). Reports on two such missions, to the Sudan
(2004) and Zimbabwe (2002), have been published.124 The report on a third mission, to Mali
and Mauritania, was not made public.
The role of NGOs
The African Charter makes no express reference to NGOs, but the rules of procedure of the
Commission authorize it to grant observer status to NGOs. Currently, 414 NGOs have formal
Since 1994, the Commission has published its decisions (on both admissibility and merits) on individual
complaints as an annex to the annual activity reports it submits to the Assembly of Heads of State of the African
Union (available from www.achpr.org). The Institute for Human Rights and Development in Africa (IHRDA) has
also published the African Commission’s decisions on communications, in two volumes covering the periods
1994-2001 and 2002-2007 respectively (available from ww.ihrda.org/documents).
121
Resolution on the Criteria for Granting and Enjoying Observer Status to Non-governmental Organizations
Working in the Field of Human Rights with the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights adopted at
the 25th Ordinary Session of the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights, Bujumbura, Burundi, 5
May 1999.
122
Communications Nos. 25/89, 47/90, 56/91 and 100/93, Free Legal Assistance Group and Others v. Zaire
(1995).
123
Available from www.achpr.org/english/_info/reports_en.html (accessed 4 December 2012).
124