A/HRC/15/37/Add.4
representative organizations, of the NTER measures in their current form in regard to
income management, leasing and alcohol restrictions.19
35.
In November 2009, the Government introduced into Parliament draft legislation to
reinstate application of the Racial Discrimination Act and the anti-discriminations laws of
the Northern Territory, and to reform essential aspects of the NTER. In doing so the
Government indicated its openness to constructive feedback from all stakeholders on the
specifics of the proposed reforms. The Special Rapporteur welcomes this development and
encourages the ultimate adoption of reforms to the NTER that fully comport with
Australia’s international human rights obligations.
V.
Conclusions and recommendations
36.
The Government should continue its commitment to address problems faced by
Aboriginal people in the Northern Territory, in particular concerning the well-being
of Aboriginal women and children. However, any measures should involve a holistic
approach, which recognizes the interdependent character of human rights, and must
be devised and carried out with due regard of the rights of indigenous peoples to selfdetermination and to be free from racial discrimination and indignity.
37.
Aspects of the NTER as currently configured are racially discriminatory and
incompatible with Australia’s international human rights obligations. These include
aspects related to compulsory income management, compulsory acquisition of
Aboriginal land, the assertion of extensive powers by the Commonwealth Government
over Aboriginal communities, and alcohol and pornography restrictions in prescribed
areas, as well as the other provisions of the NTER listed in paragraph 13, supra.
38.
The Government and Parliament should reinstate the Racial Discrimination
Act, as the Government has committed to do, and should enact appropriate reforms to
the NTER in light of all of Australia’s international human rights obligations.
Further, such reforms should be developed on the basis of full and adequate
consultations with the affected indigenous peoples.
39.
Any discriminatory measures or limitations to the human rights and
fundamental freedoms of indigenous peoples that remain part of the NTER
programme must be narrowly tailored, proportional, and strictly necessary to achieve
the legitimate objectives being pursued.
40.
Additionally, such limitations on rights should exist only on the basis of the
free, prior and informed consent of the indigenous peoples concerned. Where this is
not possible because of exigent circumstances, due regard should be given to the full
range of applicable human rights norms. In any case, any measure that accords
differential treatment to indigenous peoples or that limits their human rights and
fundamental freedoms should fulfil the requirements of “special measures” under
applicable human rights standards, including the Convention to Eliminate
Discrimination.
41.
Efforts should be made to reach agreements in accordance with the
organizational patterns and leadership structures of the diverse indigenous
19
GE.10-13887
It is noteworthy that the Government report on the consultations states that the information contained
therein “should be read as a summary of the information recorded during the consultations. It should
not be considered to be representative of all the opinions of those affected by the NTER measures”.
Government Report on Consultations, p. 19.
35