A/HRC/7/19/Add.2
page 13
C. Perceptions and reactions of State officials and Government agencies
45. The majority of state authorities recognized the existence of racism and discrimination in
Estonia, whilst highlighting the actions and programmes taken by the government to fight these
problems. The Prime Minister, in particular, stated that although some people in Estonia, as in
other countries, are intolerant and even violent towards foreigners, the Government has a very
strong stance against this behaviour. This stance is reflected in the Constitution and other
legislation, which unambiguously prohibit any form of racism and discrimination. The
Government’s position is to recognize the problems of the past as a means to avoid them in the
future. In this regard, the Prime Minister made a specific reference to the issue of anti-Semitism
and the collaboration of Estonians with the perpetrators of the Holocaust, emphasizing that the
Government had already formally apologized for this period of history and is taking all measures
to protect the Jewish community.
46. The Prime Minister also recognized the complex situation of the Russian minority,
especially in view of the recent historical background. He highlighted important differences
within the Russian community, which reached Estonia in different historical periods over the
past two centuries, from the arrival of the old believers to the more recent wave of migration
during Soviet times. The Prime Minister pointed out that the Russian community has refrained
from engaging in nationalist parties, which has allowed for the strengthening of non-ethnic,
mainstream parties.
47. The Special Rapporteur asked government interlocutors about the high number of stateless
persons. Most authorities saw the large number of persons of undefined nationality not as
evidence of discrimination, but rather as an outcome of large-scale historical processes that
placed communities in conflictive situations. Some state authorities, particularly the Chancellor
of Justice, recognized that the elevated number of non-citizens represents a concrete problem,
whilst underlining the positive steps taken by the Government in order to facilitate the granting
of citizenship. According to many authorities, the simplification of citizenship application,
including of language requirements, directly contributed to the reduction of the number of
persons of undefined nationality from around 500,000 in the early 1990s to 112,000 at present.
48. One of the barriers to reducing the number of stateless persons, according to some State
officials, is a lack of incentives for non-citizens to apply for citizenship. In particular, it was
pointed out by many authorities, including the Ministers of Interior and Justice, that over the past
years, the Government has made a strong effort to facilitate citizenship procedures, which in
their views transformed Estonia’s legislation into one of the most liberal in the world. In the
view of many authorities, many non-citizens choose not to apply for citizenship because of the
limited additional benefits of becoming a citizen.
49. The Prime Minister also focused on the need to bridge the gap in the interpretation of
history between the Estonian and Russian communities, particularly regarding symbolic events
such as the Second World War, collaboration with the Nazis and the meaning of the Soviet
occupation. This gap in historical perceptions was demonstrated in April 2007, during the crisis
around the relocation of a monument in homage to the Soviet soldiers that died during the
Second World War. A problem mentioned by some authorities is that history has been
instrumentalized in some occasions in order to question the right of Estonia to exist as a