A/53/279
to them in connection with the fifty-fourth session of the
Commission on Human Rights: Afghanistan, Albania, Angola,
Azerbaijan, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Comoros, Gabon,
Georgia, Iran (Islamic Republic of), Latvia, Mauritania,
Mongolia, Mozambique, Myanmar, Nepal, Nicaragua,
Nigeria, Pakistan, Portugal, Qatar, Russian Federation,
Somalia, Sudan, United Arab Emirates, Uzbekistan, Yemen
and Yugoslavia.
V. Conclusions and recommendations
84. It must be recognized that, as the communications of
the Special Rapporteur indicate, manifestations of intolerance
and discrimination based on religion and belief, including
violent manifestations, continue to occur throughout the
world.
85. However, the Special Rapporteur has observed, through
the various categories of violations developed in the course
of the analysis, the following trends in matters of religion and
belief:
(a) State policies against religion and policies
designed to control religious matters in the name of a political
ideology have declined, even though, on the one hand, such
phenomena do persist in several countries and, on the other,
problems arising from such policies, including the restitution
of religious property confiscated under previous regimes, still
persist in others;
(b) State policies against minorities in matters of
religion and belief, especially against non-recognized
communities such as sects or new religious movements, are
on the rise;
(c) More and more policies and practices of
intolerance and discrimination in the field of religion and
belief are being implemented by non-State entities. On the
one hand there are the religious communities, which operate
on two levels – between communities and within
communities. The representatives of such communities and
their followers first turn on members of their own faith, within
the same branch or in a different branch; this is illustrated by
the status of women as reflected in the sixth category of
violations and the status of converts as reflected in the third
category of violations. These representatives and their
followers then mobilize against communities of different
faiths. The second category of non-State actors, that
sometimes overlaps with the first category, concerns politicalcum-religious parties or movements such as the Taliban.
These two categories raise the issue of the relationship
between politics and religion, and the use of these to foment
intolerance and discrimination, culminating in religious
extremism;
(d) Policies and practices that discriminate against
women, because of their status which is determined by men’s
interpretation of religion and religious traditions, have
increased. It should be stressed that this trend affects all
religions and beliefs and occurs in one form or another
throughout the world.
86. Concerning these trends, and bearing in mind
Commission on Human Rights resolutions 1998/18 on the
Implementation of the Declaration on the Elimination of All
Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion
or Belief and 1998/74 on Human rights and thematic
procedures, the Special Rapporteur would like to make the
following recommendations.
87. First of all, the Special Rapporteur has noticed, since
his appointment, that his mandate seemed to be limited to the
management of the manifestations of intolerance and
discrimination in matters of religion and belief. The Special
Rapporteur’s role was restricted to a posteriori interventions.
He therefore considered it necessary and urgent to establish
a role of prevention. To that end, he launched the mechanism
of in situ visits, supplemented by a visit follow-up procedure
for the recommendations made in the mission reports. The
Special Rapporteur also established an urgent appeals
procedure. He conducted a survey on problems relating to
freedom of religion and belief from the standpoint of the
curricula and textbooks of primary or elementary and
secondary educational institutions designed to help shape an
international educational strategy for combating all forms of
intolerance and discrimination based on religion or belief.
Recommendations were also made with respect to the
technical cooperation programme of the High Commissioner
for Human Rights (E/CN.4/1995/91). All these activities and
recommendations contribute to and are aimed at preventing
intolerance and discrimination in general.
88. As far as more specific questions are concerned, the
Special Rapporteur wishes to make the following comments
and recommendations.
89. Religious extremism, regardless of whether or not it has
a genuinely religious basis, is apparent or latent, adopts,
provokes or sustains violence or manifests itself in less
spectacular forms of intolerance, constitutes an unacceptable
assault on both freedom and religion. No society, religion or
faith is immune from extremism. However, when extremism
resorts to a frenzy of wanton terrorism and becomes a hideous
monster that kills in the name of God and exterminates in the
name of religion, when it engages in the most despicable acts
of barbarity, and knows no bounds in its cruelty, then silence
13