A/HRC/16/29
enumerating and measuring minority populations keeping gender stratification in mind. The
tool begins with a discussion on existing practices of defining and measuring gender and
minority status. It highlights the measurement of challenges and concludes with some
recommendations for more consistent data collection and analysis on gender and minority
status.
28.
It is important to underline how the paper recognizes that producing reliable data
may be problematic due to the lack of confidentiality. It is also important to note that
despite the provision of individual data protection, minority individuals may still not be
confident enough to disclose their real identities due to distrust towards Government claims
that individual data are intended for fair treatment rather than discrimination. The paper
recommends that the free and self-declaration of respondents remains an essential principle
in the collection of official data on migrant and ethno-cultural characteristics of individuals.
29.
The paper also highlights that in some countries, it is sensitive to directly identify
minority status by race, ethnicity or religion. In these countries it may be useful to use the
country of birth (parents’ country of birth or ancestry) as a proxy for ethnicity to identify
the ethno-cultural characteristics of minority groups. It also specifies that where data
collection is by self-completion forms, clear instructions to respondents need to be
communicated appropriately. Finally the paper suggests that involvement of minority
communities in the data collection is helpful to establish trust and improve data quality.
VIII.
World Health Organization: Health Equity and Ethnic
Minorities in Emergency Situations (2007)
30.
In Health Equity and Ethnic Minorities in Emergency Situations the World Health
Organization presents two types of experiment on the development of intersectoral action
applying a broad approach to public policy and a human rights-based approach to ethnic
groups in Colombia. The first type includes projects applied generally to these
communities, primarily “Aboriginal or Afro-Colombian”, using strategies in which the
human rights approach methodology was not made explicit. The second type includes
projects with an explicitly defined ethnic human rights-based approach, where cultural
perspectives of the community were considered and programmes were adapted to their
needs. The lessons drawn from the experiments are proposed as tools in implementing
programmes for reducing inequality in health services among the most vulnerable
population groups and in particular ethnic groups. The main finding is that projects that
make specific reference to ethnic minorities and use a human rights-based approach are
more successful in addressing the causes of discrimination and in providing equal access to
health care.
31.
The creation and adoption of an emergency and disaster relief care plan for
“Aboriginal or Afro-Colombian” communities in diminishing the vulnerability and
exposure of ethnic minority populations to the internal armed conflict also proved
particularly effective. Moreover the coordination and integration of the initiatives of the
development sectors involved have led to increased recognition at the national level of the
need for affirmative action to benefit “Aboriginal, Afro-Colombian, Raizal and Romani
peoples”.
IX.
Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination:
“Early Warning Indicators” (2007)
32.
The Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination has established an early
warning mechanism to draw the attention of Member States to situations where racial
8